Granta 31: The General : Book Review

In the anthology "Granta 31," edited by Bill Buford, readers are treated to a diverse and captivating collection of short stories that highlight the talent and range of several gifted writers. Each story offers a unique and thought-provoking perspective, taking readers on a literary journey that is engaging and unpredictable.

Buford's selection is remarkable in its ability to showcase the strengths of each author and their distinctive writing styles. One standout story in the collection is "Rattlesnakes," which takes place in the American South and is a gripping tale of survival and revenge. Buford's careful curation of this story demonstrates his keen eye for stories that captivate and resonate with readers.

Another notable contribution to "Granta 31" is "Mrs. Worsley," a deeply moving story that explores themes of identity, sacrifice, and the societal constraints placed on women in a patriarchal society. This story is a testament to the power of storytelling and its ability to provoke introspection and empathy.

One of the highlights of Buford's editorship is his enthusiasm and passion for literature, evident in his insightful introductions to each story. His commentary provides readers with valuable context and enhances their understanding of the authors' intentions. Buford's thoughtful approach ensures that readers can fully appreciate the depth and nuances of the stories.

The seamless flow between the stories is one of the strengths of "Granta 31." Despite the varying voices and styles, there is a unifying thread that ties the collection together thematically. This cohesion creates a satisfying reading experience, where each story builds upon the previous one, igniting curiosity for the next literary gem.

What are readers saying?

Bill Buford's book "Granta 31: The General" has received a range of reviews from readers, with varying opinions about both the content and writing style. Many readers applauded Buford's meticulous research and attention to detail in exploring the life and exploits of William Sherman, a notorious figure in American history. They found the historical background informative and appreciated the depth of information given about the Civil War era. These readers considered the book engaging and enlightening, particularly for those interested in American history and military strategy. Buford was also praised for his vivid storytelling, effectively narrating the events and capturing the essence of the time period.

However, there were readers who found the book to be dense and overwhelming. They believed that Buford's excessive use of detail made it challenging to follow and grasp the overall narrative. Some reviewers described the book as dry and lacking a cohesive structure. While they recognized the research effort, they suggested that it could have benefited from more concise writing and a stronger narrative thread.

Some readers were disappointed by the absence of character development and personal anecdotes. They felt that the focus on historical context overshadowed the personalities involved, resulting in a less engaging reading experience. Others commented that the book resembled more of an academic text rather than popular non-fiction, making it less accessible to the general reader.

Despite the mixed opinions, many readers agreed that Buford's writing style was well-suited for those who appreciate meticulously researched historical accounts. They acknowledged the author's expertise and dedication to providing a comprehensive exploration of William Sherman and his impact on the Civil War. Overall, the reviews suggested that readers with a specific interest in American history and military strategy may find "Granta 31: The General" to be a rewarding and insightful read.