Heathcliff and the Great Hunger: Studies in Irish Culture : Book Review

In his book "Heathcliff and the Great Hunger," Terry Eagleton provides a compelling analysis of Emily Brontë's renowned novel, "Wuthering Heights." Eagleton delves into the themes of hunger and desire that permeate the story, drawing intriguing parallels between Heathcliff's narrative and the Irish Great Hunger. By exploring the shared themes of hunger, violence, and longing, Eagleton invites readers to reexamine "Wuthering Heights" within the historical and cultural contexts of its time.

Eagleton's examination of hunger serves as a focal point in his analysis. He explores the various forms of hunger depicted in the novel, ranging from physical hunger to psychological and emotional cravings. By connecting the characters' desires for power, love, and revenge, Eagleton uncovers the underlying motivations that drive the conflicts in the story. Additionally, he links this hunger to the backdrop of the Irish Great Hunger, shedding light on the socioeconomic implications of Brontë's work.

The theme of violence is another crucial aspect of Eagleton's analysis. He analyzes the recurring acts of violence in "Wuthering Heights" and argues that they mirror the brutalities experienced during the Great Hunger. By drawing parallels between the physical violence inflicted upon characters and the suffering of Irish peasants, Eagleton highlights the destructive consequences of societal inequalities.

While examining themes of hunger and violence, Eagleton also delves into the concept of longing. He examines the deep yearnings for love, belonging, and social mobility that drive the characters' actions, linking them to the aspirations of Irish peasants during the famine. This analysis underscores the universal nature of human longing and emphasizes the shared human experiences that transcend time and place.

Through his careful analysis, Eagleton presents "Heathcliff and the Great Hunger" as a thought-provoking exploration of "Wuthering Heights" and its cultural and historical contexts. By establishing connections between Brontë's novel and the Irish Great Hunger, Eagleton unveils the underlying themes of hunger, violence, and longing that resonate within both works. This insightful book offers readers a refreshed perspective on the intricate complexities and enduring relevance of "Wuthering Heights."

What are readers saying?

"Heathcliff and the Great Hunger" by Terry Eagleton has garnered a range of opinions from readers, showcasing a mixed response to the book. Eagleton's work delves into the parallels between Irish history and Emily Brontë's iconic novel "Wuthering Heights."

Some reviewers found Eagleton's analysis to be thought-provoking and perceptive. They appreciated his exploration of themes such as oppression, colonialism, and famine, and admired the connections he drew between the struggles of the Irish people and the characters in "Wuthering Heights." These readers commended Eagleton's scholarly approach and the thoroughness of his research, noting that it contributed a fresh layer of understanding to both texts.

However, other readers felt that Eagleton's analysis was excessively intricate and difficult to follow. They found the historical context and references to be overwhelming, making it challenging to fully grasp the connections he was attempting to establish. Some reviewers also considered Eagleton's writing style to be dry and academic, lacking the accessibility required for a broader audience to engage with the book.

A common critique of "Heathcliff and the Great Hunger" was its insufficient focus on the characters and plot of "Wuthering Heights" itself. These readers believed that the book deviated too far from its initial premise, resembling more of an exploration of Irish history rather than a direct analysis of the novel. This left them feeling disappointed and yearning for a deeper examination of the characters and their motivations.

Despite these criticisms, there were also readers who thoroughly enjoyed the book and found Eagleton's connections between Irish history and "Wuthering Heights" to be thought-provoking and enlightening. They appreciated the fresh perspective Eagleton brought to both texts and lauded the depth of his analysis.

HeathcliffAndTheGreatHunger HungerInTheMoors IrishFamineTale