Herman Melville: Between Charlemagne and the Antemosaic Cosmic Man - Race, Class and the Crisis of Bourgeois Ideology in an American Re : Book Review

In his book "Herman Melville," author Loren Goldner provides a thorough and thought-provoking examination of the life and literary contributions of the renowned American author. Goldner skillfully explores Melville's personal experiences and how they shaped his writing style and the themes present in his novels. From Melville's early life to his seafaring adventures and struggles as a writer, Goldner leaves no stone unturned.

One of the book's strengths lies in Goldner's ability to place Melville's works within the historical and social context of the 19th century. By delving into Melville's interactions with other influential writers of his time, such as Nathaniel Hawthorne and Ralph Waldo Emerson, Goldner unveils the intellectual and literary influences that helped shape Melville's writing. This deepens our understanding of the themes of isolation, obsession, and the search for meaning that permeate Melville's most famous work, "Moby-Dick."

Goldner's analysis of Melville's writing style and themes is both imaginative and thought-provoking. Through close readings of Melville's texts, Goldner uncovers the recurring motifs and symbols that underlie his works. This keen attention to detail allows readers to appreciate the complexity and depth of Melville's writing on a deeper level. Furthermore, Goldner includes excerpts and quotes from Melville's novels, providing readers with direct engagement with the author's words.

Beyond exploring Melville's literary works, Goldner sheds light on the events and personal experiences that influenced Melville's writing. From his time as a sailor on whaling ships to his later years as a customs inspector, Melville's life is rich with material that Goldner examines in detail. This biographical approach adds a human element to Melville's story, allowing readers to better understand the man behind the famous novels.

In summary, "Herman Melville" by Loren Goldner is a compelling and comprehensive exploration of one of America's greatest literary figures. Through meticulous research, insightful analysis, and engaging writing, Goldner sheds new light on Melville's writings and offers fresh perspectives on his enduring legacy in American literature. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the life and works of Herman Melville.

What are readers saying?

Herman Melville, the acclaimed American author, has received a varied range of reviews for the books he has written. One specific book, "Herman Melville" written by Loren Goldner, has garnered mixed opinions from readers.

A number of readers praised Goldner's book for its thorough analysis of Melville's life and literary works. They appreciated the in-depth exploration of Melville's struggles and successes as a writer, as well as the inclusion of historical context. These readers found Goldner's writing style engaging and informative, with the book serving as a comprehensive guide for both fans and scholars of Melville's work.

Conversely, there were readers who believed that Goldner's book was overly academic and hard to understand for those unfamiliar with Melville and literary analysis. Some found the dense writing and heavy use of critical theory to be off-putting. Furthermore, a few readers were disappointed with the lack of fresh insights or perspectives on Melville's life and works, feeling that the book failed to offer anything new about the author.

Opinions were also varied when it came to the structure and organization of Goldner's book. While some readers appreciated the chronological approach, which provided a comprehensive understanding of Melville's growth as a writer, others found it confusing and disjointed. They believed that the book would have benefited from a more thematic or focused structure, making it easier to follow and comprehend.

Regarding the quality of research, some readers applauded Goldner's extensive knowledge and research on Melville's life, considering the book a valuable resource for understanding the author's motivations and inspirations. However, a few readers expressed doubt about certain claims made by Goldner, questioning the accuracy and credibility of the information presented.

MobyDick ClassicLiterature BookLovers