Herndon's Informants: Letters, Interviews, and Statements about Abraham Lincoln : Book Review

Douglas L. Wilson's "Herndon's Informants: Letters, Interviews, and Statements about Abraham Lincoln" offers a meticulous compilation of primary sources that provides fresh insights into the life and character of the iconic president. By drawing from the extensive work of William H. Herndon, Lincoln's law partner and biographer, Wilson presents a rich collection of letters, interviews, and statements from individuals who had personal interactions with Lincoln, shedding light on his thoughts, actions, and upbringing.

What makes this book truly extraordinary is its inclusion of diverse perspectives, ranging from family members and friends to colleagues and even political adversaries. Through these firsthand accounts, readers gain a deeper understanding of Lincoln's journey, his beliefs, his struggles, and his leadership style. Wilson's use of various sources adds credibility and depth to his research, painting a comprehensive portrait of the man behind the legend.

Wilson's analysis and annotations are invaluable in providing context and explanations that help readers grasp the significance of each source. He carefully evaluates the reliability of each informant, highlighting any biases or potential inaccuracies, enhancing the scholarly value of the book.

Perhaps most remarkable about "Herndon's Informants" is the abundance of previously unpublished materials it presents. Wilson's diligent research has unearthed rare letters and interviews from archives and collections, making this book a treasure trove for both Lincoln scholars and enthusiasts. The inclusion of these newly discovered sources adds fresh dimensions to our understanding of Lincoln's life and impact on American history.

In conclusion, "Herndon's Informants" is an essential read for those seeking a deeper exploration of Abraham Lincoln's life. Wilson's expertise as a Lincoln scholar, his thoughtful selection of primary sources, and his astute interpretation make this book an invaluable contribution to the field. It is sure to become a go-to resource for researchers and historians interested in gaining a comprehensive understanding of the personal and political life of one of America's most revered presidents.

What are readers saying?

Douglas L. Wilson's book, "Herndon's Informants," has garnered a range of opinions from readers. This book aims to shed light on Abraham Lincoln's early life and personal relationships through the testimonies of William H. Herndon, Lincoln's law partner and biographer, as well as various informants. Here is an overview of the reviews:

1. Positive Feedback: Some readers praised "Herndon's Informants" for its comprehensive research and valuable insights. They found the book to be well-written and commended the author's expertise in the subject matter. The detailed accounts of Lincoln's personal life and his relationships with friends and family were considered both fascinating and enlightening.

2. Criticism of Organization: Several reviewers expressed frustration with the organization and structure of the book. They felt that the information presented was fragmented or repetitive, making it challenging to follow the narrative. Additionally, some readers mentioned that the book lacked a clear focus and direction, resulting in confusion and disjointed storytelling.

3. Examination of Lincoln's Character: Some readers found "Herndon's Informants" to be an in-depth exploration of Abraham Lincoln's character and motivations. They appreciated the nuanced portrayal and the fresh perspective on the famous president. Wilson's analysis of Lincoln's relationships and personal struggles resonated with these readers.

4. Density and Academia: A few reviewers felt that "Herndon's Informants" was overly dense and overly academic. The extensive use of quotations and citations, indicative of thorough research, made the book feel dry and inaccessible to some readers. These individuals found it challenging to engage with the material and maintain focus while reading.

HerndonsInformants BookRecommendation HistoricalNonfiction