How to Write a Damn Good Mystery: A Practical Step-by-Step Guide from Inspiration to Finished Manuscript : Book Review

James N. Frey's "How to Write a Damn Good Mystery" is a comprehensive and informative guidebook that serves as an invaluable resource for aspiring writers venturing into the world of mystery novels. Drawing on his experience and expertise as a writing instructor, Frey provides a step-by-step approach that covers every aspect of the genre, from crafting an intriguing plot to developing multifaceted characters.

One of the standout features of the book is Frey's emphasis on the art of plotting. He offers valuable insights on constructing a well-crafted mystery, providing tips on building suspense, introducing unexpected plot twists, and creating a tightly woven narrative. Frey also delves into the intricacies of character development, guiding writers on how to create compelling protagonists and villains and effectively portray their motivations and relationships.

Frey's writing style is engaging and accessible, making it easy for readers to grasp the concepts he presents. Through the use of examples from popular mystery novels, he illustrates his points, enabling readers to understand how successful authors have applied these techniques in their own work.

In addition to addressing the technical aspects, Frey explores the mindset and psychology of both the writer and the reader. He delves into the expectations and desires of mystery readers and teaches writers how to deliver a satisfying experience through the strategic use of clues, red herrings, and suspense.

Overall, "How to Write a Damn Good Mystery" is a valuable resource for both novice and seasoned writers looking to hone their skills in the mystery genre. With its practical advice, insightful analysis, and inspiring examples, this book provides a solid foundation for anyone seeking to craft a compelling mystery novel. Whether you are just starting out or seeking to enhance your writing abilities, Frey's guide is an excellent tool to help you elevate your storytelling craft and captivate readers.

What are readers saying?

James N. Frey's book, "How to Write a Damn Good Mystery," has received mixed reviews from readers. Some found it to be a valuable resource for aspiring mystery writers, appreciating its practical advice and clear explanations. The step-by-step approach that Frey takes in guiding readers through the process of crafting a compelling mystery was well-received by many. The book's tips and techniques were deemed helpful in enhancing writing skills and creating engaging plots. Another aspect that received praise was the focus on character development and its significance in a mystery novel.

However, there were reviewers who had a different perspective. Some felt that the book relied too heavily on formulaic writing, lacking the creativity needed for original storytelling. They desired more diverse and innovative approaches to mystery writing. Additionally, criticisms were made regarding the book being repetitive, covering similar topics in different chapters.

Furthermore, certain aspects of writing a mystery, such as pacing and creating suspense, were considered inadequately covered. Readers were disappointed by the lack of depth and more advanced techniques that experienced writers may seek.

Overall, "How to Write a Damn Good Mystery" offers practical advice for beginner mystery writers while emphasizing the importance of character development. It has its merits, but it may not suit those looking for originality and depth. The book's usefulness to individual writers may depend on their experience level and personal preferences.