In America : Book Review

Susan Sontag's "In America" is a captivating novel that takes readers on a rich and immersive journey through the lives of a group of Polish immigrants who settle in 19th-century America. The story revolves around Maryna Zalezowska, a renowned Polish actress, and her family as they navigate the challenges and opportunities of their new land. Sontag's beautifully crafted prose explores themes of identity, art, love, and the pursuit of the American Dream.

One of the novel's strengths lies in Sontag's masterful storytelling. She skillfully weaves together multiple narrative threads, seamlessly transitioning between past and present and different perspectives. This multi-layered approach keeps the reader engaged and invested in the story. Sontag's vivid descriptions and attention to detail also contribute to the overall richness of the narrative, vividly portraying both the characters and the world they inhabit.

The characters in "In America" are complex and multidimensional, each struggling with their own challenges and desires. Maryna, in particular, is a strong and enigmatic figure, grappling with fame, love, and her own personal demons. Sontag's exploration of the immigrant experience adds depth to the characters as they navigate the complexities of American society and wrestle with questions of assimilation and cultural identity.

The novel goes beyond its compelling characters to delve into thought-provoking themes and ideas. Sontag raises questions about the nature of art, the role of the artist in society, and the power of storytelling. These philosophical musings add another layer of depth, prompting readers to reflect on the purpose and meaning of individual and collective experiences.

Overall, "In America" is a rich and immersive novel that showcases Sontag's masterful storytelling and thought-provoking exploration of identity and the immigrant experience. It is a book that both entertains and challenges readers, leaving a lasting impression.

What are readers saying?

Susan Sontag's In America has generated a range of responses from readers, with opinions on the book varying greatly. The novel follows the story of Maryna Zalewska, a Polish actress who immigrates to America in the late 19th century. Here's a summary of the feedback received.

Many readers were captivated by Sontag's writing style, applauding her ability to vividly depict characters and settings. They were impressed by her beautiful descriptions of the immigrant experience and the way she brought historical events to life. The book was praised for its emotional depth and its ability to engage readers, creating a strong investment in the lives and struggles of the characters.

Several readers appreciated the thorough exploration of themes such as identity, art, and the American Dream. Sontag's discussions on these subjects were described as thought-provoking and prompted readers to reflect on their own lives. The novel was seen as a powerful commentary on the intricacies of personal and cultural identity.

On the other hand, some readers found the story to be slow-paced and disjointed. The narrative was criticized for frequently switching between various perspectives and time periods, which made it challenging to follow. Additionally, some readers felt that the characters lacked depth and connection, hindering their ability to fully engage with the story.

There were also readers who felt that the book was excessively dense and intellectual. They found Sontag's writing style to be overly academic, making the novel inaccessible and arduous to read. These individuals often struggled to connect with the story, becoming lost in the philosophical discussions.

InAmericaBook AmericanDream LiteraryClassic