Indian Captive: The Story of Mary Jemison : Book Review

"Indian Captive" by Lois Lenski is a captivating historical fiction novel that transports readers to the late 1700s during the French and Indian War. The story follows Mary Jemison, a young girl who is captured by a Shawnee tribe and provides a vivid portrayal of her experiences and her eventual assimilation into Native American culture.

Lois Lenski's writing style is engaging and accessible, making it suitable for readers of all ages. Her descriptive details allow readers to fully immerse themselves in Mary's world and the challenges she faces. Lenski's meticulous research and attention to historical accuracy bring the time period to life, allowing readers to gain a deeper understanding of the era.

One of the strengths of "Indian Captive" is its exploration of identity and belonging. Mary navigates her new life among the Shawnee people, wrestling with conflicting loyalties and striving to find her place in both Native American and European societies. This internal conflict adds depth to the story and allows readers to emotionally connect with Mary.

The book also excels in portraying the Shawnee tribe and their way of life. Lenski's attention to detail provides an authentic depiction of Native American culture, from their traditions and customs to their beliefs and values. Through Mary's experiences, readers gain a greater understanding and appreciation for the complexities of Native American history and the impact of European colonization.

Overall, "Indian Captive" is a compelling and thought-provoking read that sheds light on a lesser-known aspect of American history. Lois Lenski's masterful storytelling and nuanced character development make this book an excellent choice for fans of historical fiction, particularly those fascinated by Native American culture and the experiences of individuals caught between two worlds.

What are readers saying?

The book "Indian Captive" written by Lois Lenski has garnered a range of opinions from readers. Overall, the book is praised for its historical and educational elements; however, some readers express concern over the romanticized depiction of Native American captivity.

Many readers commend Lois Lenski for her meticulous research and detailed portrayal of the historical context. They appreciate the educational value of the book and believe it offers valuable insights into the dynamics between Native Americans and settlers during the colonial era. The accurate depiction of Native American culture and traditions also receives accolades from reviewers.

However, some readers voice reservations regarding the romanticized portrayal of Native American captivity. They argue that the book downplays the harsh realities and traumatic experiences suffered by captives and instead presents a more idealistic perspective. Critics point out that this approach may lead younger readers to have a skewed understanding of history.

Opinions on the character development in "Indian Captive" are divided. Some readers find the main character, Mary Jemison, relatable and admire her resilience throughout the story. They appreciate the growth and transformation she undergoes as she adapts to her new life and community. However, others feel that Mary lacks depth and complexity, making it challenging for them to fully connect with her as a character.

In terms of writing style and pacing, readers have differing opinions. Some find Lois Lenski's descriptive prose captivating and engaging. On the other hand, a number of reviewers find the writing style outdated and the pacing slow, which hinders their ability to stay engaged with the story.

IndianCaptive HistoricalFiction NativeAmerican