Intellectuals: From Marx and Tolstoy to Sartre and Chomsky : Book Review

"Intellectuals" by Paul Johnson provides a thought-provoking exploration into the lives and ideas of influential intellectuals from various historical periods. Johnson skillfully delves into the paradoxical nature of these individuals, who often possess great intellectual prowess but have also contributed to the miseries of the world through misguided beliefs and actions.

Throughout the book, Johnson presents insightful biographical sketches of intellectuals such as Rousseau, Shelley, Marx, Ibsen, and Freud, among others. He examines their personal lives, their beliefs, and the societal impact of their ideas. One of the key arguments presented by Johnson is that many intellectuals have used their intelligence to advocate for radical ideologies that have had disastrous consequences, such as supporting totalitarian regimes or undermining traditional values.

A prominent theme in "Intellectuals" is the disconnect between the lofty ideals advocated by intellectuals and their personal lives. Johnson emphasizes the hypocrisy of these individuals, revealing how they often fail to live up to the values they espouse. By meticulously analyzing their characters, he exposes the contradictions and flaws that frequently undermine the credibility of their ideas.

In addition to critiquing the intellectuals themselves, Johnson questions the blind adoration that society often bestows upon them. He suggests that intellectuals should be held accountable for the consequences of their ideas rather than idolized solely for their intellect. He challenges the commonly held notion that intelligence and morality necessarily go hand in hand, encouraging readers to critically evaluate the authority and influence of intellectuals on society.

Overall, "Intellectuals" offers a thought-provoking analysis of the lives and legacies of influential intellectuals throughout history. It serves as a cautionary reminder to critically evaluate ideas and the individuals behind them, rather than blindly following intellectual elites. Through thorough research and compelling arguments, Johnson's book stimulates meaningful reflection on the intersection of intellect, ideology, and the impact of ideas on society.

What are readers saying?

The book "Intellectuals" by Paul Johnson has garnered mixed reviews. In general, readers find it to be thought-provoking and informative, providing a critical analysis of the intellectual class. However, there are some who believe that Johnson's arguments are biased and lack depth.

Many reviewers appreciate how Johnson offers a comprehensive examination of famous intellectuals throughout history. They find the book engaging and well-researched, with Johnson providing intriguing insights into the lives and beliefs of influential figures. These readers feel that the book prompts them to question the idolization of intellectuals, ultimately challenging their perspectives on intellectualism.

On the other hand, some readers criticize Johnson for his strong conservative bias. They argue that his opinions overshadow the analysis, resulting in a lack of objectivity. Some reviewers also feel that Johnson oversimplifies complex ideas and reduces the motivations of intellectuals to simple character flaws. They find his criticism of the intellectual class to be one-dimensional and dismissive.

Furthermore, a few reviewers find the book lacking in depth. They argue that Johnson's analysis tends to be superficial, focusing only on surface-level details of the lives and ideas of intellectuals. These readers would have preferred a more comprehensive examination of the intellectual landscape, feeling that the book falls short in this regard.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still find "Intellectuals" to be a worthwhile read. They appreciate Johnson's ability to shed light on the human side of intellectuals, offering insights into their personal lives and the impact their ideas have had on society. The book successfully challenges readers to reevaluate their perception of intellectuals, even if they may not always agree with Johnson's arguments.

ThinkersUnite IntellectualLounge BookwormWisdom