It Never Snows in September: The German View of Market-Garden and the Battle of Arnhem, September 1944 : Book Review

"It Never Snows in September" by Robert Kershaw is a captivating historical book that deeply explores the events surrounding Operation Market Garden in World War II. Kershaw's meticulous research and interviews with survivors bring to life the realities, challenges, and sacrifices faced by the soldiers involved in this ambitious Allied operation.

One of the book's strengths is its detailed coverage of the complex planning behind Operation Market Garden. Kershaw expertly analyzes the decisions made by key military leaders, providing insight into the strategic calculations and high hopes that shaped the operation. By exploring the failures and missed opportunities, Kershaw offers a comprehensive understanding of why Market Garden fell short of its objectives.

What truly sets this book apart is its focus on the personal stories of the soldiers who fought in Operation Market Garden. Kershaw gives voice to their experiences and examines the physical and psychological impact that war had on them. The inclusion of these individual perspectives adds depth and emotions to the narrative, making it a gripping read.

Kershaw's writing style is engaging and accessible, allowing readers to easily follow the complex military strategies and maneuvers involved. The book's structure seamlessly moves between different aspects of the operation and effectively incorporates firsthand accounts. Kershaw's attention to detail and vivid descriptions of the wartime landscape make readers feel as though they are right alongside the soldiers.

Overall, "It Never Snows in September" provides an immersive and well-researched account of Operation Market Garden. Robert Kershaw's careful approach and emphasis on personal stories create a compelling narrative that offers valuable insights into this pivotal moment in history. Whether you have a passion for history or a general interest in World War II, this book is an excellent choice.

What are readers saying?

"It Never Snows in September" by Robert Kershaw is a highly acclaimed book that delves into the story of Operation Market Garden during World War II. The book has received overwhelmingly positive reviews, with readers praising Kershaw's meticulous research, gripping storytelling, and ability to accurately capture the events and emotions of the soldiers involved.

Reviewers consistently mention the extensive research conducted for the book, commending Kershaw for his attention to detail. Readers appreciate the in-depth interviews with survivors of the operation, which contribute to a comprehensive and authentic portrayal of the events. Kershaw's commitment to historical accuracy is highly praised, providing readers with a deeper understanding of the true nature of Operation Market Garden.

The compelling storytelling in "It Never Snows in September" is another aspect that receives high praise. Kershaw skillfully weaves together the personal stories and experiences of the soldiers involved, creating a vivid and engaging narrative that captivates readers from start to finish. Reviewers frequently comment on how the book brings to life the fear, bravery, and sacrifice of the men who participated in the operation, making it both captivating and emotionally resonant.

Readers also appreciate Kershaw's ability to provide a balanced perspective of the events. Despite Operation Market Garden being a failed mission, Kershaw portrays the decision-making process and the challenges faced by the commanders with nuance and understanding. This allows readers to see the operation from multiple angles, resulting in a more well-rounded and insightful reading experience.

Overall, the reviews for "It Never Snows in September" commend Robert Kershaw for his exceptional portrayal of Operation Market Garden. The combination of meticulous research, gripping storytelling, and balanced perspective makes this book a must-read for history enthusiasts and anyone interested in World War II. Kershaw's ability to bring the events to life and capture the emotions of the soldiers involved is highly praised, solidifying it as a highly recommended and well-regarded book.

NeverSnowsInSeptember WWIIDrama HistoricalNonfiction