J.R.R. Tolkien : Book Review

In his book on J.R.R. Tolkien, Harold Bloom offers a comprehensive and thought-provoking analysis of the renowned author's works. Bloom delves into Tolkien's literary achievements, exploring the intricacies of his writing style and providing insightful interpretations of his fantasy novels. This book is an invaluable resource for both Tolkien fans and scholars interested in understanding the genius behind his storytelling.

Bloom's analysis delves deep into Tolkien's works, offering rich detail and demonstrating a profound understanding of the author's themes and techniques. He explores Tolkien's distinctive narrative voice, masterful world-building, and the complex characters that inhabit his stories. Through his exploration of the multiple layers of meaning within Tolkien's works, Bloom allows readers to develop a deeper appreciation for the depth and complexity of Tolkien's storytelling.

One of the book's strengths lies in Bloom's ability to connect Tolkien's work with the broader literary canon. Drawing on his extensive knowledge of literature, Bloom places Tolkien in conversation with other great writers, emphasizing the unique qualities that set Tolkien's writing apart. This comparative approach enhances our understanding of Tolkien's contribution to the fantasy genre and his place within the wider literary tradition.

Bloom's prose is both scholarly and accessible, making this book a rewarding read for academics and casual readers alike. His passion for Tolkien's work shines through, and his enthusiasm is contagious. While Bloom offers his own interpretations and analysis throughout, he also encourages readers to develop their own understanding and engage with Tolkien's works on a personal level.

Overall, Harold Bloom's book on J.R.R. Tolkien is a must-read for anyone interested in exploring the profound influence and literary significance of this beloved author. Bloom's deep knowledge and insightful analysis provide readers with a fresh perspective on Tolkien's works, making this book a valuable addition to any Tolkien enthusiast's library.

What are readers saying?

Harold Bloom's book delving into the works of J.R.R. Tolkien has elicited a range of responses. While some readers admire Bloom's profound understanding of Tolkien's writing, others fault the book for its overly critical stance towards the fantasy genre.

Certain reviewers commend Bloom for his insightful analysis of Tolkien's themes, characters, and world-building. They appreciate his ability to contextualize Tolkien's work within the larger literary tradition, as well as his exploration of the influences, philosophy, and mythology prevalent in Tolkien's creations. These readers find Bloom's examination of these aspects enlightening and enriching.

However, there are readers who believe that Bloom's criticism of Tolkien's writing is unwarranted and heavy-handed. They argue that his dismissive attitude towards the fantasy genre undermines his analysis. These individuals argue that Bloom fails to recognize the imaginative prowess and storytelling techniques that have garnered Tolkien a vast and dedicated following.

A common critique among some reviewers pertains to Bloom's writing style, which they find convoluted and inaccessible. They express their dismay at the utilization of dense language and obscure references, which they consider off-putting and distracting. These readers assert that Bloom's excessively academic approach alienates casual readers and limits the book's wider appeal.

Furthermore, several reviewers express disappointment with the book's organization and structure, perceiving it as lacking a cohesive narrative. They contend that the book's exploration of various topics feels disjointed and rushed, failing to provide a comprehensive and coherent analysis of Tolkien's works.

TolkienFan MiddleEarthChronicles EpicFantasy