J.R.R. Tolkien: Myth, Morality, and Religion : Book Review

Richard L. Purtill's book on J.R.R. Tolkien provides readers with a captivating and thorough examination of the life and work of this legendary author. With deep insights and a comprehensive approach, Purtill explores the various influences and experiences that shaped Tolkien's writing, as well as the profound philosophical and theological themes embedded within his works. This book not only analyzes Tolkien's renowned novels such as "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit," but also delves into lesser-known texts and essays, offering a comprehensive view of Tolkien's literary world.

What sets Purtill's book apart is its skillful connection of Tolkien's work to wider philosophical and theological ideas. Purtill delves into Tolkien's Catholic faith and how it influenced his writing, exploring the moral and spiritual themes that resonate throughout his works. Through this exploration, Purtill uncovers the depth and complexity of Tolkien's writings, shedding new light on familiar stories and characters for readers.

Moreover, Purtill provides valuable insights into Tolkien's creative process and his intricate world-building techniques. He explores the languages and mythologies Tolkien crafted for his fictional universe, as well as the social and historical contexts that influenced his storytelling. By doing so, Purtill offers readers a deeper understanding and appreciation for the richness and intricacies of Tolkien's literary creations.

Additionally, Purtill's book acts as a useful introduction to Tolkien's lesser-known works. While "The Lord of the Rings" and "The Hobbit" may be the most popular, Purtill also explores texts such as "The Silmarillion" and "The Notion Club Papers," providing readers with a more comprehensive perspective on Tolkien's literary output.

In conclusion, Richard L. Purtill's book on J.R.R. Tolkien is essential reading for both casual readers and devoted fans of Tolkien's work. It offers a comprehensive and insightful analysis of Tolkien's life, influences, and writing, while illuminating the profound philosophical and theological themes within his works. Purtill's engaging writing style and astute analysis make this book an invaluable resource for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of Tolkien's literary world.

What are readers saying?

Richard L. Purtill's book exploring the works of J.R.R. Tolkien has garnered a range of reviews, with a mix of positive and critical feedback. Overall, readers appreciate Purtill's analysis of Tolkien's writings, which delves into the deeper meaning behind the author's stories. However, some reviewers have found the book to be overly technical and academic, making it challenging to fully engage with.

Many readers applaud Purtill's insightful interpretations of Tolkien's works, describing the book as a thought-provoking exploration of the themes, symbolism, and philosophy found in Tolkien's stories. Purtill's analysis enhances readers' understanding of the underlying messages and values conveyed by Tolkien, making it a valuable resource for fans and scholars alike.

On the other hand, some reviewers find Purtill's writing style to be excessively academic. They feel that the book is overly technical and filled with complex terminology, which makes it a demanding read for those seeking a more accessible analysis of Tolkien's works. Some readers also note that Purtill's analysis can be repetitive at times, lacking depth and originality.

Despite these criticisms, many readers appreciate Purtill's ability to draw connections between various elements of Tolkien's works. The book is widely regarded as well-researched and comprehensive, providing readers with a deeper appreciation for the intricate world Tolkien created.

In addition, certain readers express disappointment with the book's organization and structure. They find it somewhat disjointed, with sections that lack cohesion and fail to connect smoothly. This affects the overall flow of the book, hindering readers' enjoyment.

TolkienWorld MiddleEarthAdventure BookwormsDelight