Literature for Composition: Essays, Fiction, Poetry, and Drama : Book Review

Sylvan Barnet's 'Literature for Composition' is a thoroughly engaging textbook that offers students a wide range of literary selections and tools to enhance their writing abilities. What sets this book apart is its thematic organization, as each section explores a unique aspect of literature, exploring different genres such as fiction, poetry, and drama. By including a diverse selection of classic and contemporary works, Barnet ensures that students gain a comprehensive understanding of various literary forms and perspectives.

One of the main strengths of this textbook is its strong emphasis on writing. Barnet recognizes the intertwined relationship between literature and composition, making sure to include numerous writing prompts and exercises to help students develop their analytical and argumentative writing skills. These prompts are well thought out and provoke deep analysis, pushing students to explore the texts and form their own opinions.

Beyond the selection of literary works, 'Literature for Composition' also provides students with helpful tools and resources. Barnet guides readers on effective strategies for reading and analyzing literature, equipping them with tips on identifying key themes, symbols, and literary devices. Additionally, the book offers detailed guidelines for structuring and developing persuasive essays, providing students with a clear roadmap for constructing compelling arguments.

The book's thoroughness in analyzing texts and providing insightful commentary is another aspect that sets it apart. Barnet's analysis of the literary selections is clear and perceptive, stimulating critical thinking and helping students deepen their understanding of the works. By integrating literary analysis into the overall learning experience, 'Literature for Composition' enables students to not only appreciate literature but also to engage with it on a deeper level.

In sum, 'Literature for Composition' by Sylvan Barnet is an invaluable resource for literature and composition courses. Its comprehensive selection of diverse and meaningful literary works, practical writing exercises, and insightful analysis make it an essential tool for developing students' skills and fostering a deep appreciation for literature.

What are readers saying?

The book "Literature for Composition" by Sylvan Barnet has received a mix of reviews from readers. While some readers appreciate its comprehensive coverage and helpful recommendations for writing essays, others find fault with its structure and lack of depth.

Many readers praise the book for its thoroughness. They find the selection of readings to be diverse and interesting, encompassing a wide range of literary genres and styles. The book's focus on writing techniques and strategies also receives positive feedback, as readers appreciate the practical advice provided for developing their writing skills. Additionally, the inclusion of sample essays and analysis is seen as beneficial for learning how to effectively interpret and write about literature.

However, some readers have criticized the book's organization. They find it confusing and lacking a clear structure, making it difficult to navigate the content. This can be particularly frustrating for students who are using the book as a textbook or guide for their writing assignments. Furthermore, some readers feel that the flow of the book is disjointed, with concepts not being effectively connected from one chapter to another.

Another criticism of "Literature for Composition" is its perceived lack of depth. Some reviewers express disappointment in the book's superficial treatment of literary analysis, feeling that it only scratches the surface of important concepts. They argue that the book could have delved deeper into critical thinking and literary interpretation, providing more thorough analysis and examples.

Despite these criticisms, many readers find value in "Literature for Composition" and consider it a useful resource for writing essays. They appreciate its coverage of literature and the practical tips it offers for effective writing. However, the issues with organization and perceived lack of depth mentioned by some readers are cause for concern. Ultimately, opinions on the book will vary depending on individual needs and expectations.

LiteratureForComposition BookReview WritingInspiration