"Managers Not MBAs" by Henry Mintzberg is a highly thought-provoking and insightful book that challenges the traditional approach to business education and advocates for a more well-rounded approach to developing effective managers. Mintzberg argues that the current emphasis on theoretical knowledge and detached case studies in MBA programs is insufficient in preparing individuals for the complexities of managing real-life organizations.
The book offers a strong critique of the MBA curriculum, highlighting its overreliance on quantitative analysis and its neglect of the value of practical experience in cultivating managerial skills. According to Mintzberg, being an effective manager requires a combination of practical know-how, interpersonal skills, and a deep understanding of the organization and its context. He suggests that the development of managerial competence should be an ongoing process that involves continuous learning, personal reflection, and hands-on experience.
One of the main themes in the book is the importance of experiential learning. Mintzberg advocates for a shift towards more active learning methods, such as internships, mentoring, and job rotations, which allow individuals to hone the skills needed to navigate the complexities of management. He also underscores the significance of observation and thoughtful reflection in the development of managerial competence, urging aspiring managers to learn from their own experiences as well as the experiences of others.
Available on Audible
Throughout the book, Mintzberg provides numerous examples and anecdotes to illustrate his arguments and offer practical insights for managers. His writing style is engaging and easy to understand, and he draws from a variety of industries and organizational contexts to add depth and relevance to his ideas.
In conclusion, "Managers Not MBAs" is a compelling and eye-opening book that challenges conventional wisdom about managerial education and offers a fresh perspective on what it takes to be an effective manager. Mintzberg's ideas are presented in a thoughtful and practical manner, making this book a valuable resource for both aspiring and experienced managers. It serves as a reminder that true managerial competence is not solely derived from a degree, but rather from a lifelong commitment to learning and real-world experience.
What are readers saying?
Henry Mintzberg's book "Managers Not MBAs" has received a range of reviews from readers, providing a comprehensive understanding of its content and impact. Some readers highly praise Mintzberg's perspective on the traditional MBA education system. They appreciate his argument that real-world management skills cannot simply be taught in a classroom setting. These reviewers find value in his suggestions for alternative methods of developing managerial capabilities, such as apprenticeships and on-the-job learning. They feel that Mintzberg presents a compelling case for reevaluating the current MBA system. Others, however, express disappointment with the book, critiquing Mintzberg for being overly critical of MBAs without sufficient evidence or concrete solutions. These reviewers argue that while MBA programs may have flaws, they still provide valuable knowledge and skills for managers.
Some readers appreciate Mintzberg's work but find it challenging to read. They commend his extensive research and wealth of knowledge but note that the book can be academically focused and dense. These readers suggest approaching the book with prior knowledge of the business and management field, as it may not be easily accessible to those unfamiliar with the subject matter. Other reviewers highlight Mintzberg's emphasis on experience and practical learning over theoretical knowledge. They appreciate his insights and anecdotes about successful managers without formal business education. These readers find inspiration in Mintzberg's message and believe it opens up opportunities for a more inclusive approach to developing managerial skills.
Overall, "Managers Not MBAs" has sparked important discussions about the value of traditional MBA programs and the need for alternative paths to managerial success. Mintzberg's perspectives and arguments have resonated with many readers, challenging prevailing norms and prompting a reevaluation of how managers are educated and prepared for their roles.
leadershipmatters managerialbooks careeradvancement