Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity : Book Review

"Manhood in the Making: Cultural Concepts of Masculinity" by David D. Gilmore offers a captivating exploration of how masculinity has been shaped and defined across different cultures and time periods. Through extensive research and analysis, Gilmore argues that masculinity is not a fixed, innate quality but rather a socially constructed concept that varies across societies.

Gilmore delves into the cultural perspectives on masculinity, examining rituals, behaviors, and expectations associated with manhood in various cultures. By understanding these diverse cultural conceptions of masculinity, he challenges the notion of a universal definition of manhood and encourages readers to question their own cultural assumptions.

One of the most intriguing aspects of Gilmore's argument is his emphasis on the performative nature of masculinity. He posits that masculinity is not a passive state but an active performance, shaped by daily actions and narratives. This perspective sheds light on how individuals navigate societal expectations and how these performances can either reinforce or challenge traditional gender norms.

Gilmore also explores the complex relationship between gender and masculinity, investigating how men relate to women and the impact of patriarchal systems. He explores how masculinity functions as a tool of power and control, while also acknowledging that men themselves can be constrained by societal expectations.

"Manhood in the Making" provides a comprehensive examination of masculinity, drawing on interdisciplinary research from anthropology, history, and gender studies. Through this approach, Gilmore offers readers a nuanced understanding of the complexities of masculinity and invites them to critically analyze their own cultural assumptions.

What are readers saying?

The book "Manhood in the Making" by David D. Gilmore has elicited a range of opinions from readers. It delves into the concept of manhood across different cultures and historical periods, specifically focusing on the transition from boyhood to manhood. While some readers found the book to be enlightening and thought-provoking, others felt that it lacked depth and failed to provide a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter.

A notable aspect of the book appreciated by several reviewers is its cross-cultural approach. They found it fascinating to explore diverse perspectives on manhood and applauded the extensive research conducted by the author. These readers commended the book for broadening their understanding of various cultural norms and expectations for men, viewing it as a valuable source of insights into the complexities of manhood.

On the other hand, some readers found "Manhood in the Making" to be lacking in depth and academic rigor. They perceived the book as relying too heavily on generalizations and anecdotes rather than offering a well-rounded analysis. Some reviewers also criticized the repetitive nature of the writing, as certain ideas were reiterated throughout the book.

Additionally, a few readers raised the issue of the author's narrow focus on heterosexual manhood, while neglecting the experiences and perspectives of non-binary and LGBTQ+ individuals. These reviewers argued that the book should have taken a more inclusive approach, recognizing that manhood encompasses a diverse range of identities and experiences.

Despite these mixed reviews, "Manhood in the Making" still managed to resonate with many readers. Those who enjoyed the book appreciated the author's exploration of masculinity from various angles, as well as his accessible writing style. However, some readers felt that the book could have delved deeper into the subject matter and taken a more inclusive approach to better represent the diverse experiences surrounding manhood.

ManhoodInTheMaking GenderRoles SelfDiscovery