In his book "Manliness and Masculinities in Nineteenth-Century Britain," John Tosh offers a deep and thorough examination of the concept of manliness and its various expressions during the 19th century in Britain. With meticulous research and analysis, Tosh dives into the societal, cultural, and historical context that shaped masculinity during this transformative period.
Tosh explores the multifaceted nature of manliness by delving into the construction and performance of masculinity across different social classes and professions. He investigates the ideals and expectations of masculinity, shedding light on how they influenced men's behavior, interactions, and roles within society. Through the inclusion of primary sources such as personal diaries, letters, and memoirs, Tosh brings the experiences and perspectives of ordinary men to the forefront, providing a more authentic and inclusive understanding of masculinity in the 19th century.
The book also highlights the influence of societal changes on notions of manliness. Tosh skillfully explores how industrialization and the rise of the middle class impacted masculinity, revealing the tensions and anxieties that arose as men grappled with new social and economic roles. By placing manliness within this broader context, Tosh paints a comprehensive picture of the complexities surrounding masculinity during this era.
Available on Audible
Overall, "Manliness and Masculinities in Nineteenth-Century Britain" is a compelling and insightful exploration of masculinity during a pivotal period in British history. Tosh's extensive research and nuanced analysis provide a comprehensive understanding of how manliness was constructed, challenged, and negotiated in 19th-century Britain. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of gender and the intricate nature of masculinity.
"Manliness and Masculinities in Nineteenth-Century Britain" by John Tosh has garnered a range of reviews from readers. While some have lauded the book as a well-researched and insightful exploration of masculinity during the Victorian era, others have criticized it for its dense and academic nature.
Many readers praised John Tosh for his extensive research, considering the book to be a valuable resource for those interested in the history of masculinity. They appreciated his comprehensive analysis of various aspects of manliness, including its connection with the emerging middle-class, its influence on literature and the arts, and its association with colonialism. Readers found the book to be thought-provoking, crediting Tosh for his ability to draw connections between historical events and social norms concerning masculinity.
However, some readers found the book excessively academic and challenging to read. They felt that Tosh's writing style was dry and dense, making it difficult to engage with the material. Some readers also believed that the book lacked a cohesive narrative, instead appearing as a series of disconnected analyses. Additionally, critics noted that the book had an excessive focus on the perspective of the upper-class, which sidelined the experiences of men from other social classes.
Despite these criticisms, many readers regarded the book as an important contribution to the study of masculinity. They appreciated Tosh's endeavors to question traditional notions of manliness and his exploration of the various factors that shaped masculinity in nineteenth-century Britain. Overall, "Manliness and Masculinities in Nineteenth-Century Britain" is recommended for those with a keen interest in this topic, though it may not be suitable for readers seeking a more accessible and engaging read.