May and Amy: A True Story of Family, Forbidden Love, and the Secret Lives of May Gaskell, Her Daughter Amy, and Sir Edward Burne-Jones : Book Review

May and Amy is a deeply moving memoir written by Josceline Dimbleby that chronicles the lives of two remarkable women who lived on a remote farm in Cornwall during the early 1900s. This poignant book explores the numerous challenges and triumphs faced by May and Amy Ghilchik, a mother and daughter duo.

Dimbleby skillfully captures the tranquillity and serenity of the farm, painting a vivid portrait of a haven amidst a rapidly changing world. The author's descriptive prowess transports readers to the Cornwall countryside, allowing them to truly experience the fresh air and picturesque landscapes alongside May and Amy.

The complex and meaningful mother-daughter relationship between May and Amy is a particular highlight of the memoir. Dimbleby delves deep into their bond, presenting it as both loving and strained at times. The depth of their connection is beautifully portrayed as they navigate various obstacles together, relying on one another for support and resilience.

Throughout the book, Dimbleby carefully contextualizes the lives of May and Amy within the historical and societal framework of the early 20th century. She sheds light on the struggles faced by women in rural England during this time, highlighting their tenacity and determination in the face of societal limitations.

May and Amy is a captivating memoir that is sure to resonate with readers who appreciate stories of strong and resilient women. Dimbleby's evocative writing style and meticulous attention to detail bring the past to life, offering readers a glimpse into a bygone era while celebrating the extraordinary lives of May and Amy Ghilchik. This heartwarming book is a must-read for those seeking an immersive and emotionally impactful reading experience.

What are readers saying?

May and Amy is a novel authored by Josceline Dimbleby that revolves around the lives of two sisters, May and Amy. Reviews for the book have been varied, with readers expressing different opinions on the overall story, characters, and writing style.

Many readers praised the book for its well-developed characters and the strong bond between May and Amy. They found the sisters relatable and enjoyed following their journey. Additionally, the historical setting and details were extensively researched and added depth, providing a vivid backdrop for the story.

However, some readers felt that the pace of the book was slow and that the plot lacked excitement. They desired more action and unexpected twists to maintain their interest. A few readers also mentioned that the writing style lacked depth, which affected their overall enjoyment of the book.

Opinions on the portrayal of the time period and societal norms also varied among readers. Some appreciated the accurate representation of the historical setting, including the challenges faced by women during that time. However, a few readers felt that the book failed to critically examine these societal issues, instead presenting them through a romanticized lens.

The romance subplot in the book also received mixed feedback. Some readers found it engaging and believed it added depth to the characters and their relationships. However, others found the romance cliché and predictable, detracting from the overall story.

#MayAndAmy #GoodreadsBooks #SistersInLiterature