Mel Bay Presents Irish Mandolin Playing: A Complete Guide : Book Review

"Mel Bay Presents Irish Mandolin Playing" by Philip John Berthoud is an exceptional resource for individuals eager to learn the mandolin, with a particular emphasis on Irish music. This book offers a comprehensive introduction to the instrument and covers important aspects such as tuning, holding the mandolin, and fundamental techniques like picking and strumming.

What distinguishes this book is its dedicated focus on Irish music. Berthoud dives into a wide range of traditional tunes such as jigs, reels, and airs. Not only does he provide the sheet music for these tunes, but he also includes accompanying chord symbols. Moreover, each piece is accompanied by insightful notes and tips on ornamentation and phrasing, which helps readers develop a deeper understanding of the unique musical style of Ireland.

One of the book's strong points is Berthoud's practical and accessible approach, making it suitable for both beginners and intermediate players. The author offers clear explanations of various techniques, including playing chords, double stops, and slides. These instructions are reinforced by helpful diagrams, ensuring that readers can easily follow along and apply what they've learned.

In addition to the instructional content, "Mel Bay Presents Irish Mandolin Playing" provides valuable background information on the history and significance of Irish music. Berthoud delves into the various types of tunes and their cultural importance, enhancing the overall learning experience and fostering a deeper appreciation for the genre.

In conclusion, "Mel Bay Presents Irish Mandolin Playing" is a comprehensive and well-crafted guide for mandolin players interested in exploring Irish music. Whether you are a beginner or an intermediate player, this book offers valuable instruction, a diverse selection of tunes, and insightful information that will enrich your understanding and enjoyment of Irish music.

What are readers saying?

Philip John Berthoud's book, "Mel Bay Presents Irish Mandolin Playing," has received a mix of reviews from readers. On the whole, the book offers a comprehensive introduction to playing the mandolin in the Irish tradition, although some readers found it lacking in certain aspects.

One aspect that garnered positive feedback was the clarity and conciseness of the book's instruction. Many readers appreciated Berthoud's step-by-step approach, which made it easy for beginners to follow along. The book covers various techniques specific to Irish mandolin playing, including ornamentation and rhythmic strumming patterns.

However, some reviewers felt that the book lacked depth and complexity. They noted that the arrangements and exercises were relatively simplistic and did not offer enough challenge for more experienced players. Additionally, a few felt that the book focused too heavily on traditional Irish music and neglected other styles, which limited its variety.

Opinions on the accompanying CD were also divided. Some readers found it helpful for practicing alongside the book, as it provided examples of the techniques and tunes being taught. Others, however, found the audio quality to be subpar and felt that it could have been better produced.

Many readers appreciated the cultural and historical context provided by Berthoud throughout the book. His explanations of Irish music traditions and styles were seen as informative and enriching, enhancing the readers' understanding of the music they were learning to play.

IrishMandolinPlaying Musicbook CelticMusic