Metaphysics as Rhetoric: Alfarabi's Summary of Plato's Laws : Book Review

In his thought-provoking book "Metaphysics as Rhetoric," Joshua Parens delves into the intricate relationship between metaphysics and rhetoric, two foundational disciplines in philosophy and communication. Through an exploration of historical philosophers and key metaphysical concepts, the author challenges traditional perspectives on metaphysics by presenting it as a form of rhetorical persuasion rather than a pursuit of absolute truth.

Parens initiates his discourse by delving into the works of influential philosophers like Plato, Aristotle, and Aquinas. He highlights their utilization of metaphysics as a means of persuasion, emphasizing that metaphysics is not a neutral exploration of reality but rather intricately intertwined with the art of rhetorical communication. This unique perspective prompts readers to reconsider the purpose and influence of metaphysics, inviting them to critically reflect on its role in shaping beliefs and values.

Throughout the book, Parens meticulously analyzes key metaphysical concepts such as substance, essence, and causality, demonstrating how they can be regarded as constructs employed to persuade audiences of certain ideas. By shedding light on the persuasive nature of these concepts, the author encourages readers to reevaluate how metaphysics can shape their understanding of reality and influence their perceptions.

Furthermore, Parens addresses the significance of language in metaphysics, emphasizing that it not only describes reality but also plays a crucial role in constructing it. He argues that language and metaphysics are intricately interconnected, deepening our understanding of how rhetoric is intertwined with the construction of reality.

In "Metaphysics as Rhetoric," Joshua Parens presents metaphysics as more than just a quest for truth but as a persuasive tool for communication. By analyzing historical philosophers and exploring key metaphysical concepts, the author challenges conventional perspectives and provides a fresh insight into the relationship between metaphysics and rhetoric. This thought-provoking book invites readers to contemplate the purpose and influence of metaphysics, ultimately shaping their understanding of reality.

What are readers saying?

Metaphysics as Rhetoric, a work by Joshua Parens, has evoked varying responses among readers. The book elicits a mixed reaction, with some individuals praising its insightful analysis while others find it challenging to comprehend.

Many reviewers appreciate the book's thoughtful exploration of the connection between metaphysics and rhetoric. Parens' analysis is hailed for its engagement and intellectual stimulation. Readers commend the author's ability to delve into complex concepts and highlight the relevance of rhetoric in metaphysical discourse.

On the flip side, some readers believe that the book is excessively dense and difficult to access. They note that the writing style makes comprehension arduous, requiring intense concentration to follow the author's arguments. These individuals feel that the book assumes a certain level of prior knowledge and understanding, potentially excluding those who are less familiar with metaphysical concepts.

Several reviewers also comment on the repetitive nature of the book. They mention instances where certain ideas and points are reiterated excessively. While repetition may have been intentional to solidify the author's arguments, some readers find it unnecessary and cumbersome, perceiving that the book could have been more concise.

Despite these criticisms, many readers find significant value in Metaphysics as Rhetoric. They appreciate the diverse examples and historical references provided by the author, as they enhance their understanding of the subject matter. These individuals commend Parens for his ability to make metaphysical concepts tangible and relatable through the use of rhetoric.

MetaphysicsRhetoric PhilosophyBooks BookLovers