Mighty Fitz: The Sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald : Book Review

"Mighty Fitz" by Michael Schumacher is a gripping and detailed account of the tragic sinking of the Edmund Fitzgerald, an iconic Great Lakes freighter. Through meticulous research and compelling storytelling, Schumacher breathes life into the crew members, delves into the ship's history, and explores the events leading up to the disaster, making this book a must-read for maritime history enthusiasts.

Schumacher's ability to bring the crew members of the Edmund Fitzgerald to life is truly remarkable. Through interviews, diaries, and letters, he paints a vivid portrait of their personalities and experiences, allowing readers to form a deep connection with these individuals. This personal touch enhances our understanding of the human impact of the tragedy and the incredible bravery displayed by the crew in such dire circumstances.

One of the standout features of "Mighty Fitz" is the author's attention to detail. Schumacher painstakingly reconstructs the events leading up to the ship's sinking, exploring the various theories and investigations, and presenting readers with a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the incident. His research is thorough, and he leaves no stone unturned in his quest for the truth.

Additionally, Schumacher provides valuable historical context throughout the book. He delves into the history of the shipping industry on the Great Lakes, shedding light on the challenges and risks faced by sailors. This background information enriches our understanding of the tragedy and places the Edmund Fitzgerald within the broader context of the maritime world.

Overall, "Mighty Fitz" is an enthralling and well-researched book that offers a comprehensive account of the Edmund Fitzgerald's sinking. Schumacher's attention to detail, captivating storytelling, and personal approach make this a standout read in maritime history. Whether you are captivated by tales of adventure or moved by stories of human resilience, this book will surely leave a lasting impression.

What are readers saying?

The book "Mighty Fitz" by Michael Schumacher has received a range of reviews from readers. It delves into the captivating and heartbreaking tale of the Edmund Fitzgerald, a renowned freighter that mysteriously sank in the Great Lakes in 1975. Schumacher's meticulous research and storytelling abilities have garnered praise from some readers, while others felt that the book lacked depth and an engaging narrative.

Many reviewers appreciated Schumacher's extensive research, noting his attention to detail and thorough interviews with family members, crew, and experts. They admired his ability to vividly depict life on the Great Lakes and the events leading up to the ship's sinking. The author's evident knowledge and passion for the subject matter made the book informative and captivating.

However, some readers found Schumacher's storytelling to be lacking. They felt that the book was dry and lacked emotional depth and character development. They struggled to connect with the narrative and believed that Schumacher's writing style failed to bring the story to life. Additionally, a few reviewers mentioned that the book seemed repetitive, with excessive reiteration of details.

Furthermore, some reviewers expressed disappointment with the organization and structure of the book. They felt that it lacked cohesion and direction, with jumps between different aspects of the story. This lack of a clear and logical flow hindered their enjoyment of the book and made it difficult to follow the sequence of events.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still considered "Mighty Fitz" to be a worthwhile read. They appreciated the unique historical account of the Edmund Fitzgerald and viewed the book as a valuable addition to maritime literature. While Schumacher's storytelling may not have resonated with every reader, it is clear that the book provides a comprehensive and informative exploration of the tragic fate of the ship.

MightyFitzReads ShipwreckedTales GreatLakesHistory