Moral, Believing Animals: Human Personhood and Culture : Book Review

In the book "Moral Believing Animals: Human Personhood and Culture," author Christian Smith delves into the intricate web of moral frameworks and beliefs that shape our human behavior. Smith challenges the commonly held notion that moral beliefs stem solely from reason or individual choice. Instead, he emphasizes the profound impact of culture on the formation of our moral convictions. Drawing upon insights from sociology, philosophy, and anthropology, Smith presents a compelling argument for understanding the complex interplay between culture and morality.

Smith introduces the concept of "moralistic therapeutic deism" as a prevailing cultural belief system that influences contemporary moral values. He explores how various external factors such as consumer culture, media, and education shape our moral beliefs. Smith also delves into the influence of religious beliefs on moral frameworks and examines how faith communities mold the moral convictions of their members.

Central to the book is the exploration of human personhood. Smith contends that our moral beliefs are intricately linked to our understanding of ourselves as individuals and our relationships with others. He posits that our moral frameworks are shaped by fundamental human inclinations and needs, such as love, purpose, and belonging.

Throughout the book, Smith supports his arguments through numerous case studies and examples. He highlights the significant role that culture plays in shaping our moral understanding and behavior.

In conclusion, "Moral Believing Animals" provides a thought-provoking analysis of the complexities of human moral beliefs and their relation to culture. Smith's interdisciplinary approach and insightful analysis make this book an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to comprehend how our moral convictions are formed and how they impact our individual and societal behaviors.

What are readers saying?

Christian Smith's book "Moral Believing Animals" has received generally positive reviews, with readers praising its thought-provoking and insightful exploration of morality and belief systems. The book delves into the complexities of human morality and religion, providing a compelling analysis of how these aspects shape individuals and society as a whole.

Reviewers appreciate the depth of research and scholarship evident in Smith's work. They commend his ability to present complex concepts in a clear and accessible manner, making the book engaging and comprehensible. Readers particularly enjoy how Smith combines philosophy, sociology, psychology, and anthropology to provide a multidisciplinary perspective on morality.

Smith's exploration of the relationship between morality and religion captivates many reviewers. They appreciate his balanced approach, noting that he neither dismisses nor imposes religion on the reader. Instead, Smith offers a nuanced discussion that allows readers to reflect on how their beliefs and morality intertwine.

The book's use of empirical research is also highly praised. Smith provides numerous case studies and examples, grounding his theories in real-life situations. This evidence-based approach adds credibility to his arguments and enriches the book's exploration of morality in human behavior.

While the majority of reviews are positive, some readers find the content overly dense and academic. They note that the book may not be suitable for casual readers or those seeking a more lighthearted exploration of morality. However, those who enjoy intellectually challenging reads applaud Smith's approach and believe it offers a rewarding experience for those willing to engage with the material.

MoralBelievingAnimals BooksOnMorality AnimalEthics