Murder in Tombstone: The Forgotten Trial of Wyatt Earp : Book Review

"Murder in Tombstone" by Steven Lubet is a captivating historical work that delves into the infamous gunfight at the O.K. Corral and the subsequent trial of the Earp brothers. Set in the iconic Wild West town of Tombstone, Arizona, the book provides a vivid and detailed account of the events leading up to the deadly shootout and the aftermath that unfolded.

Lubet's meticulous research and attention to detail are evident throughout the book. His portrayal of the lawlessness and chaos that plagued Tombstone in the late 19th century immerses readers in the atmosphere of the time, providing valuable context for understanding the events that took place. The author's storytelling skills are exceptional, making "Murder in Tombstone" a page-turner that keeps readers engaged from start to finish.

One of the strengths of the book is Lubet's objective approach to the controversial characters involved. He does not shy away from highlighting the flaws and contradictions of the Earp brothers, as well as their rivals, the Clantons and McLaurys. This nuanced portrayal adds depth to the narrative and offers readers a more comprehensive understanding of the individuals and their motivations.

Moreover, Lubet's analysis of the trial that followed the gunfight is thorough and insightful. He examines the testimonies, legal arguments, and strategies employed by both the prosecution and defense, shedding light on the intricacies of the American judicial system at the time. This attention to detail makes "Murder in Tombstone" not only a captivating true crime story but also a valuable resource for law enthusiasts and history buffs.

In conclusion, "Murder in Tombstone" is a well-researched and thought-provoking account of a significant event in American history. Steven Lubet's engaging storytelling, meticulous research, and objective analysis make this book a must-read for anyone interested in the Wild West, true crime, or legal history.

What are readers saying?

"Mixed reviews" have greeted Steven Lubet's "Murder in Tombstone," a book delving into the infamous gunfight at the O.K. Corral in the old wild west town of Tombstone. Some readers applauded Lubet's meticulous research and his ability to vividly bring the people and events of Tombstone to life, resulting in an immersive reading experience. They commended his engaging storytelling and descriptive writing style that captivated them from beginning to end.

However, not all readers were satisfied with the book's pacing and structure. They criticized Lubet for occasionally convoluted narratives and abrupt transitions between different timelines and perspectives, causing confusion regarding the sequence of events. These issues hindered some readers from fully grasping the story.

Opinions on character development were also divided. While some readers appreciated Lubet's nuanced and realistic portrayals of the individuals involved in the gunfight, others felt that the characterizations lacked depth. The latter group struggled to emotionally connect with the characters, resulting in a diminished engagement with the overall story.

Moreover, there were criticisms regarding the book's focus. Some readers anticipated a more comprehensive exploration of Tombstone's historical and cultural context, but felt disappointed by Lubet's heavy emphasis solely on the gunfight. They desired a broader examination of the town's history and its broader impact on the region.

In conclusion, "Murder in Tombstone" by Steven Lubet has generated a range of responses. While some readers praised the author's attention to detail and engaging storytelling, others found fault with the pacing, structure, and character development. Whether this book will appeal to individual readers ultimately depends on their preferences for historical non-fiction and how they prioritize different elements of the story.

MurderInTombstone WildWestMystery OldWestThriller