Narrative Based Evaluation: Wording Towards the Light : Book Review

"Narrative-Based Evaluation" by Marsha Harrison is a comprehensive guide that explores the use of storytelling as a powerful tool in the evaluation process. The book offers practical strategies and techniques for conducting evaluations that go beyond traditional methods, providing valuable insights and helping evaluators make sense of complex data.

One of the strengths of this book is its clear framework for understanding narrative-based evaluation. Harrison breaks down the key components of the process, making it accessible to evaluators of all levels of experience. By identifying stakeholders, collecting and analyzing narratives, and interpreting findings, evaluators can gain a complete understanding of program impact.

The author supports her ideas with real-life case studies and examples, highlighting the effectiveness of narrative-based evaluation in capturing the essence of program experiences and outcomes. She also provides practical tips for collecting narratives from different sources, ensuring a comprehensive approach to data collection.

Ethical considerations are also given due importance in this book. Harrison emphasizes the need to respect participants' stories, maintain confidentiality, and approach the evaluation process with sensitivity. By addressing potential limitations and challenges, evaluators can anticipate and address any ethical concerns that may arise.

Overall, "Narrative-Based Evaluation" offers an innovative approach to evaluation. With its clear framework, practical examples, and ethical perspective, Marsha Harrison's book provides evaluators with a resource that can enhance their evaluation practice and deepen their understanding of program impact through storytelling. Through the power of narratives, evaluators can gain unique insights that may not be captured through traditional methods, making this book a valuable resource in the field of evaluation.

What are readers saying?

The book "Narrative-Based Evaluation" by Marsha Harrison has generated a range of opinions from its readers. Some individuals found the author's evaluation approach to be refreshing and valuable, appreciating how Harrison effectively used narratives and storytelling techniques to emphasize the significance of evaluation. These readers praised the book for its practical methods and examples that could be applicable in a variety of contexts, making it a useful tool for both academics and professionals in the field of evaluation.

On the other hand, there were readers who struggled with the book's level of theoretical content, finding it difficult to comprehend. They felt that the author did not provide clear guidance and practical steps for implementing narrative-based evaluation, and expressed a desire for more concrete examples and case studies to accompany the theoretical concepts discussed.

Another perspective shared by some readers was that the book lacked depth and failed to thoroughly explore certain aspects of narrative-based evaluation. They believed that some sections were too brief and left them wanting more substantial information.

Furthermore, a small number of readers found the writing style to be dry and overly academic, making it challenging to remain engaged with the content. They suggested that the book could have benefited from a more accessible and engaging tone.

Overall, "Narrative-Based Evaluation" by Marsha Harrison has received mixed reviews. While some readers found value in the book's innovative approach and practical insights, others felt that it lacked clear guidance and depth. If you are interested in narrative-based evaluation, this book may be worth exploring, but be prepared for a potentially challenging read.

NarrativeBasedEvaluation BookReview EvaluationMethods