Northwestern Middle-Earth Gazetteer : Book Review

The "Northwestern Middle-earth Gazetteer" is an incredibly comprehensive and painstakingly researched guide that delves into the various regions and inhabitants of northwestern Middle-earth. Written by esteemed Tolkien scholars, Douglas A. Anderson and Paul A. Smith, this book provides a detailed exploration of the vibrant and captivating world created by J.R.R. Tolkien.

From the very beginning, the reader is captivated by an informative introduction that sets the stage for the exciting adventures to follow. The book then dives into a comprehensive gazetteer, offering meticulous information on a myriad of locations, including the realms of Gondor, Arnor, and Eriador. The descriptions are vivid and immersive, allowing readers to truly understand and appreciate the diverse and mesmerizing landscapes of Middle-earth.

One of the exceptional aspects of this book is its inclusion of lesser-known locations and peoples. The authors delve into the intricacies of various Elven realms, discussing the significance of the Dúnedain and exploring the enigmatic lands of the Drúedain and the Hobbits. Additionally, the book features a multitude of maps and illustrations that truly enhance the reading experience, bringing Middle-earth to life in astonishing detail.

Anderson and Smith's dedication to historical context is commendable, as they provide extensive background information for each location and people discussed. Drawing upon both Tolkien's published works and his unpublished notes, the authors ensure a comprehensive and accurate portrayal of Middle-earth. They skillfully weave together information from various sources, creating a cohesive and organized guide that is accessible to readers of all levels of familiarity with Tolkien's works.

The "Northwestern Middle-earth Gazetteer" is an invaluable resource for those seeking a deeper understanding of J.R.R. Tolkien's beloved realm. With its wealth of information, detailed descriptions, and engaging writing style, this book is a must-have for fans of Tolkien's works. Whether you are a novice or a dedicated follower of Middle-earth, this captivating guide will transport you to the enchanting realms and diverse cultures that make up this extraordinary fantasy world.

What are readers saying?

The reviews for "Northwestern Middle-Earth Gazetteer" on Goodreads are mainly positive, with readers praising the book for its detailed and immersive content. Many reviewers appreciate the extensive research that went into creating the gazetteer, which covers various locations in J.R.R. Tolkien's Middle-Earth, including Northwestern regions such as Mithlond, Eregion, and Lindon.

One reviewer describes the book as a "treasure trove" for fans of Tolkien, commending the author for providing in-depth information about the history, cultures, and geographical features of each location. They particularly highlight the quality of the maps, which they find helpful and visually appealing.

Another reviewer appreciates the book's meticulous attention to detail, noting that it adds depth and context to the world of Middle-Earth. They praise the comprehensive coverage of important characters, events, and landmarks, making it a valuable resource for any Tolkien enthusiast.

Multiple reviewers express their fascination with the author's extensive knowledge, emphasizing that the Gazetteer serves as a useful reference for both casual fans and scholars. Some readers note that the book has enhanced their understanding and appreciation of Tolkien's work, especially the more obscure areas of Middle-Earth.

While most reviewers find the book accessible and easy to follow, a few mention that the level of detail may be overwhelming for those less familiar with Tolkien's world.

MiddleEarthGazetteer NorthwesternMiddleEarth BookLovers