"Not Either an Experimental Doll: The Separate Worlds of Three South African Women" is a groundbreaking book by Shula Marks that delves into the lives of three remarkable women - Helen Joseph, Lilian Ngoyi, and Rahima Moosa - and their contributions to the fight against apartheid in South Africa. Marks's meticulous research, comprehensive analysis, and compelling narrative make this book a captivating exploration of the overlooked roles and perspectives of women in the anti-apartheid movement.
One of the strengths of "Not Either an Experimental Doll" is the extensive research conducted by Marks. She draws from a wide range of primary and secondary sources, including interviews, articles, and archival material, to provide a comprehensive understanding of the socio-political context in which these women operated. This thorough examination allows readers to grasp the personal and societal obstacles they faced.
Another strength is Marks's ability to capture the unique experiences of each woman. By delving into their backgrounds, motivations, and personal journeys, she humanizes these historical figures, making their stories relatable and inspiring. Marks also highlights the various strategies employed by Joseph, Ngoyi, and Moosa in their fight against apartheid, showcasing their resilience, bravery, and determination.
Available on Audible
Furthermore, "Not Either an Experimental Doll" offers valuable insights into the intersections of gender, race, and class. Marks examines how these identities influenced the women's experiences and how they navigated their roles as activists, wives, mothers, and community leaders. By exploring these broader issues, the book provides a nuanced understanding of the complexities faced by these women in their pursuit of equality.
Overall, "Not Either an Experimental Doll" is a captivating and enlightening book that sheds light on the often overlooked contributions of women in the struggle against apartheid. Through meticulous research and insightful analysis, Marks provides a comprehensive and nuanced understanding of the lives and legacies of Helen Joseph, Lilian Ngoyi, and Rahima Moosa. This book is essential reading for anyone interested in South African history, feminism, and the fight for social justice.
What are readers saying?
Not Either an Experimental Doll by Shula Marks has garnered a range of responses from readers. The book delves into the life of Sarah Baartman, a South African woman who was displayed as a "freak" in 19th-century Europe. While many readers praised Marks for her meticulous historical research and objective presentation of a sensitive subject, others felt that the book fell short in terms of emotional engagement. Some readers desired a more personal exploration of Baartman's experiences, rather than a purely historical account.
The extensive historical analysis provided by Marks was highly appreciated by many readers. They commended her attention to detail and objective approach in shedding light on the racially exploitative practices of the era. These readers found the book to be informative and eye-opening, providing valuable insight into the mistreatment Baartman endured.
However, others felt that the book lacked emotional depth, desiring a more intimate exploration of Baartman's experiences and feelings. They wanted to connect with her on a personal level, rather than simply perceiving her through a historical lens. Consequently, they felt that the book did not have the desired emotional impact.
A polarized response was also observed regarding the writing style of the book. While some readers found it clear and engaging, others characterized it as dry and academic, lacking storytelling and narrative flow. Those who struggled with the writing style felt disconnected from the story, making it difficult for them to stay engaged.
Additionally, the book's structure received mixed reviews. Some readers found it disjointed, lacking a clear chronology. They were confused by the non-linear narrative, which impeded their understanding of Baartman's life and experiences.
NotEitherAnExperimentalDoll UnconventionalReading LiteraryThoughtProvoking