Nothing Feels Good: Punk Rock, Teenagers, and Emo : Book Review

"Nothing Feels Good" by Andy Greenwald provides a comprehensive and insightful exploration of the emo music scene and how it has deeply affected the lives of its dedicated fans. Greenwald takes readers on a journey through the origins of emo music, its evolution over the years, and its cultural significance.

The book starts by tracing the roots of emo music back to its hardcore punk and indie rock origins, shedding light on the influences that shaped its unique sound and emotional lyrics. Greenwald explores the rise of influential bands such as Jimmy Eat World, Dashboard Confessional, and Taking Back Sunday, highlighting how their music resonated with listeners on a deep emotional level. He explores the connection between the music and the tumultuous emotions experienced by teenagers, demonstrating how emo became a cathartic outlet for many.

Greenwald's writing style is engaging and accessible, making it easy for both die-hard emo fans and newcomers to connect with the material. His passion for the music shines through in his vivid descriptions and personal anecdotes, allowing readers to fully immerse themselves in the emo experience. The book also incorporates album reviews and concert recaps, providing a well-rounded exploration of the emo scene.

One of the strengths of "Nothing Feels Good" is Greenwald's ability to delve beyond the surface level of the genre and analyze its impact on society. He examines how emo music challenged traditional gender roles and provided a sense of belonging for marginalized individuals. Greenwald also addresses the criticisms and controversies surrounding the genre, acknowledging accusations of melodrama and commercialization.

Overall, "Nothing Feels Good" is a must-read for any fan of emo music or anyone interested in understanding the cultural significance of this genre. Greenwald's thoughtful analysis and personal insights create a captivating narrative that captures the essence of emo and its profound impact on its devoted fanbase.

What are readers saying?

The reception for Andy Greenwald's book "Nothing Feels Good" among readers has been mixed. Exploring the rise of emo music in the early 2000s, the book has garnered both praise and criticism from its audience.

Some reviewers commend Greenwald for his thorough research and insightful analysis of the emo music scene. They appreciate his exploration of the genre's history and evolution, as well as its cultural impact. These readers found the book informative and engaging, providing them with a deeper understanding of the emo movement and its significance.

However, some reviewers were disappointed with the book's lack of coherence and its failure to capture the essence of emo music. They felt that Greenwald's writing style was disjointed and filled with unnecessary details, detracting from the overall reading experience.

Critics also argue that the book relies too heavily on personal anecdotes and opinions, which undermine its credibility and make it harder to trust the presented information. They expected a more objective analysis of the emo music scene.

On the other hand, there are readers who appreciate Greenwald's personal touch, finding his anecdotes and opinions relatable and enjoyable. They argue that his passion for the subject shines through in his writing, adding an authentic and engaging element to the book.

NothingFeelsGood BookLovers MusicTherapy