Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House : Book Review

"Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" by Judi Barrett offers a delightful twist on the well-known nursery rhyme. This children's book presents an urban adaptation in which Old MacDonald is the owner of a lively and diverse apartment house. The story introduces readers to a range of farm animals who have embraced city life.

Judi Barrett's creativity truly shines in her reimagining of the beloved nursery rhyme. Each tenant in the apartment house brings a unique personality to the story. From a pig who enjoys playing the accordion to a cow who pursues a career in painting, Barrett's whimsical use of language and playful rhymes make this book a joy to read aloud.

A key highlight of "Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" is the vibrant and detailed illustrations by Ron Barrett. His colorful and lively artwork brings the story to life, captivating children and allowing them to fully immerse themselves in this whimsical world. The illustrations perfectly capture the energy and spirit of the diverse cast of characters, making them even more memorable.

Beyond providing entertainment, this book imparts valuable lessons about diversity and acceptance. Through the interactions between the farm animals, children learn the importance of embracing differences and finding common ground. The inclusivity message is subtly woven throughout the story, ensuring it is accessible for young readers.

In conclusion, "Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" is a delightful retelling of the classic nursery rhyme. With its engaging storyline, beautiful illustrations, and important messages about diversity, this book is an excellent addition to any child's library. It is sure to captivate both children and adults alike and bring joy to read aloud.

What are readers saying?

"Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" by Judi Barrett has garnered a variety of responses from readers. Some praised the book for its fresh take on a traditional children's song. They found the concept of Old MacDonald residing in an apartment house rather than a farm to be innovative and appreciated the clever and imaginative illustrations by Ron Barrett. The humorous elements and wordplay within the book were enjoyed by both children and adults alike, making it a delightful read for the entire family to enjoy.

On the other hand, other readers were less enthralled by "Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House." They felt that the book did not quite capture the essence of the original song, as it seemed repetitive and lacking in substance. Some reviewers also noted that the story felt forced and disjointed, lacking a cohesive narrative.

Opinions regarding the illustrations within the book were also divided. Some readers found them whimsical and vibrant, accentuating the humor of the story. However, others felt that the illustrations were too busy and distracting, with personal preferences varying greatly. While some appreciated the intricate artwork, others found it overwhelming.

Despite the range of opinions, many agreed that "Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" was an enjoyable and lighthearted read, particularly for children familiar with the original nursery rhyme. The book was seen as a creative reinterpretation of a beloved classic and, although it may not have resonated with everyone, it undoubtedly brought laughter and delight to those who appreciated its humor.

Overall, "Old MacDonald Had an Apartment House" prompted a variety of responses from readers. Some embraced the playful concept and relished the comical illustrations, while others felt it fell short in comparison to the original nursery rhyme. If you are seeking a unique twist on a classic children's song, this book may be worth exploring, although it may not appeal to everyone's taste.

OldMacDonaldHadAnApartmentHouse BookwormFavorite ModernTwistOnAClassic