Onion John : Book Review

" Onion John" by Joseph Krumgold is a heartwarming tale about a young boy named Andy Rusch and his unlikely friendship with a mysterious character named Onion John. The story takes place in a small suburban town in New Jersey during the 1950s and explores various themes such as friendship, community, and the challenges of societal expectations.

Andy, an imaginative and curious boy, becomes fascinated by Onion John, a local eccentric who communicates in broken English and lives a simple life. Despite the initial language barrier, Andy and Onion John bond over their love for nature and their shared inquisitiveness about the world. Through their interactions, Andy learns the importance of accepting people for who they truly are, rather than judging them based on societal norms.

As their friendship grows, Andy faces the pressure to conform to his family's expectations and the ambitions of his community. He finds himself torn between his loyalty to Onion John and his desire to fit in. The book sensitively explores themes of identity, culture, and the struggle to find one's place in society.

Krumgold's writing is engaging, filled with vivid descriptions that transport readers to a simpler time and a world constrained by societal norms. The author pays attention to detail, creating a richly textured setting that brings the world of Andy and Onion John to life.

"Onion John" is a timeless coming-of-age story that beautifully captures the essence of friendship, acceptance, and the power of staying true to oneself. Joseph Krumgold's novel is a touching and thought-provoking read that will resonate with readers of all ages. It serves as a reminder that true friendship knows no bounds and that accepting others for who they truly are is a valuable lesson that can transcend societal expectations.

What are readers saying?

Onion John is a novel written by Joseph Krumgold that has garnered a diverse range of reviews from readers. The book follows the story of Andy Rusch, a young boy who forms a deep friendship with Onion John, an immigrant from Holland who becomes a significant influence in his life.

Some readers have commended Onion John for its heartwarming and thought-provoking narrative. They appreciate Joseph Krumgold's exploration of themes such as friendship, acceptance, and the value of cultural diversity. These reviewers find Onion John to be a relatable and inspiring character, and they highlight the positive impact he has on Andy's life. Furthermore, they enjoy the book's depiction of small-town America and the way it captures the triumphs and challenges of immigrant life.

However, there are readers who feel that Onion John comes across as outdated and lacking in depth. They believe that the story and characters do not undergo significant development, which makes it difficult for them to fully connect with the narrative. Some reviewers mention that they found the writing style simplistic and not as engaging as they had anticipated.

Additionally, a few readers criticize the pacing of the book, stating that it feels slow and lacks excitement. They desire more action and conflict to drive the story forward. Moreover, some readers think that the book's message about cultural acceptance and embracing differences is oversimplified and could have been explored in a more nuanced manner.

Overall, while Onion John has received both positive and negative feedback, it remains a book that resonates with many readers. The heartwarming tale of friendship and the exploration of cultural diversity are appreciated by some, while others feel that the book lacks depth and engaging writing. Ultimately, the reception of Joseph Krumgold's Onion John depends on the reader's personal preferences and expectations.

OnionJohnBook ChildrensBooks ClassicLiterature