Patriarcha and Other Writings (Cambridge Texts in the History of Political Thought) : Book Review

The book "Patriarcha and Other Writings" by Robert Filmer is a significant literary work that brings together various political writings by the author. At the heart of this collection lies Filmer's theory of patriarchal authority, which posits that monarchs derive their power and authority directly from a divine source. His most renowned work, "Patriarcha," serves as the centerpiece of this collection, presenting his theory in a logical and persuasive manner. Filmer adeptly draws upon biblical references and historical examples to provide evidence for his claims.

Filmer's exploration of political authority is intricately tied to religious beliefs, as he argues that the first ruler was appointed by God to govern and rule over the people. This concept, known as the divine right theory, forms the foundation of his ideas regarding the legitimacy and necessity of absolute monarchy.

In addition to "Patriarcha," this collection includes other writings by Filmer that further elaborate on his political theories. These additional texts offer readers a deeper understanding of Filmer's perspective, as well as the historical and intellectual context in which his ideas flourished. They provide valuable insights into the political thought of the seventeenth century, shaping the discourse of the time.

Filmer's writing style is marked by clarity and conciseness, ensuring that his arguments are accessible and understandable to readers. While some may find his theories controversial or outdated in modern times, it is important to recognize the significant influence they had during the seventeenth century.

Overall, "Patriarcha and Other Writings" is an invaluable collection for those interested in political philosophy and the historical development of political thought. It offers a comprehensive examination of Filmer's theories on patriarchal authority and its implications for political power. Regardless of whether one agrees or disagrees with his arguments, this book presents a thought-provoking exploration of a pivotal strand of political theory from the seventeenth century.

What are readers saying?

Robert Filmer's book "Patriarcha and Other Writings" has received a range of reviews from readers, with varying opinions on its merits. While some appreciate Filmer's historical perspective on political theory and the significance of patriarchal authority, others criticize his arguments as outdated and problematic.

Certain readers commend Filmer's extensive knowledge of political theory and history, praising his exploration of the origins and justifications of patriarchy. They recognize the historical value of the book and appreciate the insights it provides into the mindset of thinkers from the 17th century. Furthermore, they acknowledge the influence of Filmer's ideas on subsequent political thought.

However, there are reviewers who find Filmer's arguments flawed and his ideas outdated. They do not find his defense of absolute paternal authority convincing, and argue that his beliefs are patriarchal and oppressive. These readers suggest that Filmer's arguments lack depth and fail to acknowledge the diversity of family structures and power dynamics.

A common criticism among some readers is the readability of the book. They find Filmer's writing style challenging to follow, with convoluted sentences and dense language. These readers feel that the book may be more suitable for academic study rather than casual reading.

Nevertheless, a few reviewers appreciate the inclusion of additional writings by Filmer, as they contribute to a more comprehensive understanding of his perspective. They find the contextualization of his main work through these supplementary essays valuable, although some believe that these additional writings are less engaging or less well-developed.

PatriarchaAndOtherWritings PoliticalPhilosophy ClassicLiterature