Philosophy of Religion : Book Review

"Philosophy of Religion" by John Harwood Hick delves into various philosophical perspectives on religion, offering readers a comprehensive exploration of the subject. Hick, a well-respected philosopher and theologian, skillfully navigates the complexities of religious belief and its implications for the nature of God, religious language, and the problem of evil.

The book begins by examining the concept of God, guiding readers through a discussion of arguments both for and against belief in a divine being. Hick expertly presents classical arguments such as the cosmological and ontological arguments, while also tackling contemporary challenges to traditional notions of God. This thorough analysis encourages readers to critically assess their own beliefs, laying a solid foundation for further exploration.

A notable strength of Hick's book lies in his exploration of religious language. He addresses the inherent difficulties in expressing religious experiences and beliefs through human language, acknowledging its limitations and the potential for miscommunication. Through thought-provoking examples and engaging discussions, Hick invites readers to reflect on the nature of religious language and its relationship to religious experience.

Furthermore, Hick tackles the enduring problem of evil, a challenge that has long confronted religious belief systems. Drawing on a wide range of religious traditions and philosophical ideas, he evaluates various theological responses to the existence of evil in the world. Hick's nuanced approach encourages readers to grapple with the complexities of this issue and explore possible philosophical and theological resolutions.

Throughout the book, Hick's writing style is accessible and engaging, making complex philosophical concepts more approachable for readers. He carefully considers and responds to potential objections, highlighting alternative viewpoints and promoting dialogue and critical thinking.

What are readers saying?

The book "Philosophy of Religion" written by John Harwood Hick has received a mix of reviews from readers. Some readers commend the author for his comprehensive analysis and thoughtful arguments, finding his insights valuable and enlightening. They appreciate Hick's ability to present complex ideas in an accessible manner, making the book suitable for readers at various levels of familiarity with philosophy. However, other reviewers express frustration with the complexity of Hick's writing style. They believe that the book's challenging nature may be better suited for advanced readers or those well-versed in philosophy. Some readers also feel that Hick's arguments could have been presented in a more organized and clear manner to enhance comprehension.

The book's approach to religious beliefs is another aspect that draws mixed reactions from readers. While some appreciate Hick's balanced and objective perspective, acknowledging and critically analyzing various religious viewpoints, others feel that his approach may potentially be dismissive or reductionist towards certain beliefs, which could alienate some readers.

The extensive scope of the book, covering a wide range of topics within the philosophy of religion, is also mentioned by readers. While some appreciate this breadth, others feel that certain concepts are only briefly touched upon without sufficient exploration, leaving them wanting for more in-depth analysis and discussion.

Overall, "Philosophy of Religion" by John Harwood Hick provokes diverse opinions among readers. Those who enjoy complex philosophical discourse and a comprehensive overview of religious philosophy may find value in this book. However, readers seeking a more accessible and concise exploration of the subject matter might find it challenging to engage with.