Planning the Good Community: New Urbanism in Theory and Practice : Book Review

"Planning the Good Community" by Jill Grant is a comprehensive guide that explores the concept of creating sustainable and livable communities. As an urban planner and professor, Grant offers valuable insights for professionals and individuals interested in building better communities.

The book covers the fundamental principles of community planning, including social cohesion, inclusivity, and sustainability. Grant highlights the importance of understanding and meeting the desires and needs of diverse groups within a community, fostering a sense of belonging and shared responsibility.

One of the strengths of the book is its incorporation of real-life case studies. Grant provides practical examples of successful community planning initiatives and offers a critical analysis of their positive aspects and areas for improvement. This not only makes the book informative but also engaging and inspiring for readers.

In addition to case studies, Grant discusses planning theory, policy, and government regulation, providing a well-rounded perspective on the complexities of community planning. She emphasizes the dynamic relationship between planners and communities, emphasizing the need for collaboration and participatory decision-making.

Grant also addresses current challenges faced by communities, such as urbanization, gentrification, and environmental issues. She offers innovative approaches and solutions to tackle these challenges, encouraging readers to think creatively and adapt their planning strategies to changing circumstances.

What are readers saying?

Jill Grant's book, "Planning the Good Community," has received a range of reviews. While some readers appreciate the book's insights and practical advice on community planning, others criticize its lack of depth and outdated examples.

Positive reviews highlight the relevance and practicality of the book. Readers commend Grant for providing a comprehensive guide to community planning, which they find valuable and applicable in real-life situations. The book's focus on sustainability and community engagement is also well-received by those who value the creation of vibrant and inclusive neighborhoods.

However, some reviewers express disappointment with the book's lack of depth. They argue that the content feels too generic and lacks specific examples and case studies to illustrate the concepts. Some readers believe that the book falls short in addressing the complex issues surrounding community planning and fails to offer substantial solutions.

Another criticism mentioned in several reviews is the book's outdated examples. Readers note that the examples provided by Grant do not reflect the current state of community planning, which limits its relevance. They would have preferred to see more recent and diverse case studies to make it more applicable in today's context.

Despite the mixed reviews, it is clear that Jill Grant's book holds value for those seeking a general introduction to community planning concepts. It provides a broad overview of the topic, highlighting the importance of sustainable development and community involvement. However, readers looking for in-depth analysis or up-to-date examples may find the book lacking in these aspects. Overall, "Planning the Good Community" serves as a helpful starting point for individuals interested in community planning, but it may not fully satisfy those already well-versed in the subject matter.

PlanningTheGoodCommunity CommunityPlanning BooksForCommunity