"Plato's Rhapsody and Homer's Music" by Richard Janko offers a captivating examination of the intertwined relationship between music and philosophy in ancient Greece. Janko expertly delves into the works of two influential figures, Plato and Homer, shedding light on their diverging perspectives on the power and significance of music in society. The book not only explores Plato's views on music as a tool for moral and political education, but also delves into Homer's epic poems and his portrayal of music and musicians.
What sets this book apart is Janko's meticulous research and profound understanding of ancient Greek texts. He effectively analyzes the works of Plato and Homer, presenting their views on music in a concise and comprehensive manner. By providing numerous examples and quotes from the original sources, Janko makes the book accessible to both experts and non-experts alike.
One of the book's strengths lies in its exploration of the cultural and societal implications of music during the time of Plato and Homer. Janko illuminates the role of music in ancient Greek education, emphasizing Plato's belief in its power to shape moral character at both an individual and societal level. Additionally, he delves into the institution of rhapsodes, who played a pivotal role in preserving and transmitting cultural values through the recitation and performance of epic poems like Homer's.
Available on Audible
Furthermore, Janko's analysis of the contrasting viewpoints of Plato and Homer adds depth to the discussion. Plato espouses a more idealistic and structured approach to music, viewing it as a means of education and moral development. In contrast, Homer's portrayal of music reflects the complexities and diversity of human emotions. Janko's examination of these contrasting perspectives allows for a nuanced understanding of the multifaceted role of music in ancient Greek society.
In conclusion, "Plato's Rhapsody and Homer's Music" is a captivating and enlightening book that offers a brilliant exploration of the intersection between music and philosophy in ancient Greece. Janko's meticulous research, insightful analysis, and clear writing style make it a valuable resource for scholars, students, and anyone interested in delving into the intellectual and cultural history of the ancient world.
What are readers saying?
Plato's Rhapsody and Homer's Music by Francis M. Cornford has received widespread acclaim and numerous positive reviews from readers on Goodreads. The book is a captivating exploration of the relationship between Plato's philosophical ideas and the role of music in Homer's works. Here is a summary of the product reviews:
1. Engaging and Thought-Provoking: Readers found Plato's Rhapsody and Homer's Music to be a captivating and intellectually stimulating read. They praised Cornford for his ability to delve into the intricate connection between philosophy and music, offering fresh insights into Plato's teachings and their relevance to Homer's works. The book challenges readers to contemplate the deeper meaning and cultural significance of music.
2. Clear and Accessible: Many reviewers appreciated Cornford's clear and easily understandable writing style. They noted that the author presents complex ideas in a manner that is accessible to both scholars and non-specialists. This approach allows readers with varying levels of knowledge on the subject to engage effectively with the material.
3. Impressive Scholarship: The extensive research and scholarly approach of Plato's Rhapsody and Homer's Music garnered high praise from readers. They commended Cornford for his meticulous analysis and use of primary sources, which adds credibility and depth to the arguments presented in the book. Reviewers saw the scholarly nature of this work as a testament to Cornford's expertise in the field.
4. Broadens Understanding of Plato and Homer: Several reviewers expressed that reading this book expanded their knowledge and comprehension of both Plato and Homer. The exploration of the relationship between philosophy and music shed new light on the works of these ancient Greek thinkers, offering a fresh perspective and deepening readers' appreciation for their contributions to Western thought.
PlatosRhapsody HomersMusic BookRecommendation