Playing Indian : Book Review

In "Playing Indian" by Philip J. Deloria, the author delves into the intricate history of Native American representation in popular culture. Through thorough research and thought-provoking analysis, Deloria explores how non-Native individuals and groups have embraced and reimagined Native American identities for their own purposes.

Deloria begins the book by examining the historical context of "playing Indian," tracing its origins back to colonial times. He uncovers how early European colonizers adopted Native American clothing and rituals to portray themselves as rugged and authentic in the unfamiliar wilderness. This appropriation of Native culture has evolved over time and found expression in various forms such as Wild West shows, fraternal orders, and sports mascots.

One of the strengths of the book is Deloria's ability to navigate the complex terrain of cultural appropriation and self-expression. He demonstrates that "playing Indian" is not a homogeneous phenomenon, but rather encompasses a range of motives and experiences. Through exploration of different modes of performance, he raises pertinent questions regarding power dynamics, commodification, and the construction of new identities.

Throughout the book, Deloria challenges readers to critically examine the impact of "playing Indian" on Native communities. He discusses how these performances have perpetuated harmful stereotypes and marginalization, while also acknowledging instances where Native individuals and communities have reclaimed these representations for their own cultural and political empowerment.

"Playing Indian" is an engaging and well-researched book that sheds light on a crucial aspect of American cultural history. Deloria's insights and analysis provoke thought and encourage readers to question the ethical implications of cultural appropriation and self-representation. This book will undoubtedly appeal to those interested in Native American studies, cultural anthropology, and the power dynamics of representation.

What are readers saying?

"Playing Indian" by Philip J. Deloria takes readers on a thought-provoking journey through the phenomenon of cultural appropriation of Native American culture. Delving into the borrowing and manipulation of Native American elements by non-native individuals and groups, Deloria explores motives behind this appropriation for entertainment, political statements, and personal identity construction. The book has garnered mixed reviews, with some commending Deloria's extensive research and thorough analysis, while others critique certain aspects of his arguments.

Many reviewers praise Deloria's well-researched analysis, appreciating his elucidation of the historical context surrounding the portrayal of Native Americans and its impact on both native and non-native communities. They find his writing style engaging, accessible, and effective in conveying complex ideas.

Deloria's exploration of cultural appropriation within a broader social and political context is also widely applauded by reviewers. They highlight his examination of power dynamics and motivations behind non-native individuals' desire to "play Indian" as an important perspective on the implications of cultural appropriation.

However, some reviewers offer critical perspectives on certain aspects of the book. They argue that Deloria's arguments are somewhat repetitive, making the book feel prolonged, suggesting that further editing could have streamlined the message and enhanced readability.

Additionally, a few reviewers criticize Deloria for primarily focusing on the perception of Native Americans by non-native individuals, neglecting the voices and experiences of actual Native American communities. They argue that a more balanced approach would have strengthened the author's overall argument.

PlayingIndian NativeRepresentation CulturalAppropriation