Plows, Plagues, and Petroleum: How Humans Took Control of Climate : Book Review

In his book "Plows, Plagues, and Petroleum," William F. Ruddiman offers readers a captivating and thought-provoking analysis of the intricate connection between human activities and the Earth's climate over the past 8,000 years. Through meticulous research and compelling arguments, Ruddiman challenges the conventional belief that humans only began significantly altering the climate during the Industrial Revolution.

Ruddiman presents compelling evidence to support his theory that human-induced climate change actually began thousands of years ago, particularly with the emergence of agriculture. He argues that early farming practices, such as deforestation and rice cultivation, released substantial amounts of greenhouse gases, leading to significant climate changes. Moreover, he attributes the relative climate stability seen over the past millennia to the agricultural practices of early civilizations, which actually counteracted natural cooling trends.

One of the book's strengths is Ruddiman's ability to successfully balance scientific detail with accessibility. He presents complex scientific concepts in a clear and concise manner, ensuring that readers without a scientific background can grasp the key ideas. Additionally, he incorporates a range of disciplinary perspectives, including paleoclimate data, historical records, and archaeological evidence, to construct a convincing case for his argument.

"Plows, Plagues, and Petroleum" is not solely a historical analysis of past climate changes; it also holds significant implications for understanding current and future climate trends. By demonstrating that humans have been altering the climate for thousands of years, Ruddiman raises crucial questions about the role of human activities in recent climate change. He urges readers to carefully consider the long-term consequences of our actions and emphasizes the necessity of sustainable practices to mitigate potential impacts of global warming.

All in all, "Plows, Plagues, and Petroleum" is an engrossing and meticulously researched book that challenges traditional notions of human-induced climate change. With its accessible writing style and compelling arguments, it is a must-read for anyone seeking a deeper understanding of the intricate relationship between human civilization and the Earth's climate throughout history.

What are readers saying?

The book "Plows, Plagues, and Petroleum: How Humans Took Control of Climate" by William F. Ruddiman has had a mixed reception among readers. While some appreciate the author's thorough research and thought-provoking ideas, others find the arguments to be weak or repetitive.

Many reviewers commend Ruddiman's extensive research and the depth of his analysis. They appreciate his ability to integrate scientific evidence and historical data, which provides a comprehensive understanding of the subject. Readers found his presentation of the impact of human activities on the climate throughout history to be educational and eye-opening.

However, some readers found the arguments in the book to be unconvincing. They criticized Ruddiman's hypothesis that early agriculture significantly contributed to climate change, finding it somewhat speculative. They felt that the author did not provide enough evidence to support his claims, which left them unconvinced by his central argument.

Another concern raised by readers is the repetitive nature of the book. Some found the continual repetition of the main points and supporting evidence to be tiresome and unnecessary. They believed that the book could have been condensed without losing its informative value.

Additionally, some readers noted that the book might be too technical and detailed for those without a background in climate science. They found certain sections difficult to follow and suggested that a more accessible writing style or clearer explanations would have been beneficial.

PlowsPlaguesPetroleum HistoricalBook IndustrialRevolution