Poor People's Movements: Why They Succeed, How They Fail : Book Review

In "Poor People's Movements" by Frances Fox Piven, the author offers a comprehensive analysis of social movements driven by the poor in the United States. This insightful book explores the strategies, dynamics, and outcomes of these movements, highlighting their vital role in challenging deeply entrenched power structures and advocating for change.

Piven begins her analysis by providing a historical backdrop to these movements, tracing their roots back to the Great Depression and the civil rights era. By delving into the motivations and grievances of the poor, she uncovers the social and economic factors that drive their mobilization.

Throughout the book, Piven emphasizes the significance of disruptive tactics employed by these movements. Given the exclusion of the poor from conventional channels of power, protest, civil disobedience, and other direct actions become necessary to make their voices heard. Piven presents compelling examples of how such movements have effectively disrupted the status quo, leading to substantial policy changes.

A notable strength of "Poor People's Movements" is Piven's meticulous examination of the relationship between these movements and political elites. She scrutinizes how politicians and policymakers respond to the demands of the poor, shedding light on the concessions they make as well as the resistance they mount to uphold existing power structures.

Overall, Piven's book provides thought-provoking insights into the role of the poor in shaping social change. By analyzing the challenges they face and the strategies they employ, she offers valuable understanding of their fight for basic rights and improved living conditions. "Poor People's Movements" is essential reading for anyone seeking to comprehend the dynamics of social movements and the potential of collective action in driving meaningful change.

What are readers saying?

Frances Fox Piven's book, "Poor People's Movements," has received a variety of reviews, offering different perspectives on its content. Overall, the book has been commended for its insightful analysis and deep understanding of social movements, particularly those led by marginalized communities. However, some critics pointed out that the book's focus on historical movements overshadowed its examination of contemporary perspectives.

Many readers appreciated Piven's thorough research and compelling arguments. They found her exploration of various movements, such as the civil rights movement and labor strikes, to be thought-provoking and well-supported. Piven's examination of the strategies and tactics employed by poor communities to bring about social change was regarded as enlightening and empowering.

The historical context provided in the book was admired by some reviewers. They praised Piven's ability to situate the movements within their respective time periods and shed light on the challenges faced by poor individuals throughout history. By delving into the efforts of these movements, Piven offered readers a comprehensive understanding of the intricate dynamics involved in advocating for social justice.

However, some readers expressed disappointment with the book's lack of a contemporary viewpoint. They felt that Piven placed excessive emphasis on past events and did not adequately address current social movements and issues. Some reviewers believed that the book would have been more impactful if it had incorporated more recent examples and an analysis of the evolution of movements over time.

Overall, "Poor People's Movements" has received positive feedback. Readers praised Piven's insightful perspective on the strategies and challenges faced by marginalized communities in their pursuit of social change. Nonetheless, the book's historical focus and limited examination of contemporary movements left some readers desiring more. Despite this criticism, many readers found Piven's work to be educational, thought-provoking, and filled with valuable insights into the power of collective action.

PoorPeoplesMovements SocialJustice CivilRights