Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper - Case Closed : Book Review

In her book, "Portrait of a Killer: Jack the Ripper - Case Closed," Patricia Cornwell offers a captivating and extensively researched exploration into one of history's greatest unsolved mysteries. With the help of modern forensic techniques and her deep understanding of crime writing, Cornwell dives into the identity of Jack the Ripper, challenging traditional theories and reaching a controversial conclusion.

Cornwell's book is a thrilling and informative read, brimming with a wealth of information and intriguing insights. She meticulously examines the available evidence, ranging from crime scene photographs to police reports and personal letters, to construct a compelling case against the prime suspect. Through her attention to detail, she vividly recreates the Victorian era, transporting readers to the gritty streets of Whitechapel and the pervasive terror that consumed London during the Ripper's reign.

One of Cornwell's notable strengths is her ability to seamlessly blend historical analysis with cutting-edge forensic science. Consulting experts from various fields, she incorporates advancements in DNA analysis and behavioral profiling to support her theories. These scientific techniques not only bolster the credibility of her arguments but also provide a fresh perspective on the Jack the Ripper case.

It is important to acknowledge that Cornwell's conclusions have sparked controversy. Identifying the Ripper as the artist Walter Sickert has garnered both support and opposition from Ripper enthusiasts and experts alike. However, regardless of one's personal standpoint, it is undeniable that Cornwell presents a compelling case, supported by extensive evidence and her expertise as a crime writer.

Overall, "Portrait of a Killer" is a gripping exploration of Jack the Ripper's identity, underpinned by meticulous research and a unique approach that combines historical analysis with modern forensic science. Cornwell's ability to breathe life into the past and challenge conventional theories makes for an enthralling read. Regardless of one's stance on her controversial conclusion, this book is a must-read for anyone intrigued by true crime and the enduring enigma of Jack the Ripper.

What are readers saying?

Patricia Cornwell's book, Portrait of a Killer, which delves into the identity of Jack the Ripper, has garnered a range of responses from readers. Some readers commend the author's extensive research and dedication in unearthing the truth behind the infamous case. They find her exploration of forensic evidence and her attempts to connect the dots to be fascinating, offering a fresh perspective on the mystery.

On the other hand, some reviewers express disappointment with the book, suggesting that Cornwell's theories and conclusions are based on speculation rather than concrete evidence. They criticize the author for relying too heavily on her own biases and interpretations, which they believe weakens the overall argument. They argue that a historical investigation of this magnitude requires more rigor and objectivity.

Another common criticism is that the book often goes off on tangents, diverting attention from the central focus of Jack the Ripper’s identity. Some readers find these detours distracting and unnecessary, leading to a disjointed reading experience.

A few reviewers also mention the repetitive nature of the book, where certain points and theories are reiterated excessively. This repetition can make the reading experience tiresome, especially for readers already familiar with the Jack the Ripper case and similar arguments.

In conclusion, while some readers appreciate Cornwell's efforts to unravel the mystery of Jack the Ripper, others find her book lacking in strong evidence and objective analysis. The diverging tangents and redundant content further diminish the book's overall quality. Readers with a deep interest in true crime and the Jack the Ripper case may still find value in Cornwell's investigative approach, but others may find it less compelling.

PortraitOfAKiller TrueCrime BookRecommendation