Posing as People: Three Stories, Three Plays : Book Review

"Posing as People" by Orson Scott Card is a brilliant collection of short stories that truly showcases the author's remarkable versatility and boundless imagination. Each story presents readers with a unique premise and delves deep into a variety of themes, including artificial intelligence, identity, and the very essence of what it means to be human. Card's storytelling prowess shines throughout the book, effortlessly blending elements of science fiction, fantasy, and even horror.

One particular standout in this collection is the thought-provoking story titled "Lifeloop." In this tale, Card delves into the fascinating concept of immortality through digital consciousness. He skillfully navigates the ethical dilemmas and existential questions that arise when one's mind is uploaded into a computer program, leaving readers both captivated and unsettled as they contemplate the consequences of artificial immortality.

Another notable gem in "Posing as People" is the heartwarming and humorous story called "In the Doghouse." Card takes a delightful twist on the timeless bond between humans and their canine companions, exploring the idea of a telepathic connection between a dog and its owner. The endearing characters and witty dialogue within this tale make it an absolute joy to read.

Card also ventures into the realm of horror with "A Plague of Butterflies," a chilling story set in a small town where a sinister infestation of butterflies spreads a deadly disease. This particular tale is a testament to Card's ability to build suspense and create a vivid atmosphere. It keeps readers on the edge of their seats, thoroughly engaged and unsettled throughout.

Overall, "Posing as People" is a captivating collection of stories that truly displays Orson Scott Card's mastery of the short form. With his imaginative concepts, skillful writing, and thought-provoking themes, Card delivers a range of tales that will entertain and leave readers pondering the intricacies of the human condition. Whether you are a fan of science fiction, fantasy, or simply enjoy engaging and thought-provoking short stories, this book is an absolute must-read.

What are readers saying?

Posing as People, a collection of short stories by Orson Scott Card, encompasses a blend of science fiction and fantasy genres, showcasing the author's versatility. The book comprises nine distinct stories, each exploring different themes and concepts. Readers' opinions on the collection, however, have been divided.

Many readers praised the book for its imaginative storytelling and the depth of its characters. They found Card's writing style engaging and appreciated the thought-provoking nature of the stories. The blend of science fiction and fantasy elements also resonated positively with these readers. They found the stories to be diverse and explored a range of interesting concepts and ideas.

Conversely, some reviewers were less impressed, feeling that the stories lacked originality and were too predictable. They criticized Card for relying too heavily on common tropes, and felt that the narratives could have been more compelling. Additionally, these readers found certain stories confusing and disjointed, which hindered their overall enjoyment of the collection.

Another point of contention among reviewers was Card's portrayal of female characters. Some readers found the characters to be one-dimensional and lacking agency, a recurring flaw they noticed in Card's writing. However, there were others who appreciated the diversity of characters and believed that Card portrayed them realistically within the context of the stories.

The pacing of the stories also sparked discussion among readers. While some found the pacing to be well-balanced, others felt that certain stories dragged on and could have benefitted from tighter editing. These readers tended to prefer the shorter stories in the collection, finding them to be more succinct and impactful.

PosingAsPeople SciFiNovel MindBending