Post Punk Diary: 1980-1982 : Book Review

"Post Punk Diary" by George Gimarc is a must-read for music enthusiasts and historians alike. This comprehensive chronicle delves into the influential post-punk music era, spanning from 1978 to 1983. With meticulous attention to detail, Gimarc takes readers on a journey through the rise and fall of various bands, their key performances, and the impact they had on the music landscape.

One of the most notable aspects of this book is Gimarc's dedication to including both popular and lesser-known bands. This allows readers to gain a well-rounded understanding of the vibrant and diverse post-punk scene. By incorporating interviews, song lyrics, and behind-the-scenes anecdotes, the author provides readers with a deeper insight into the artists and their creative vision.

Gimarc's vivid descriptions bring the energy and creativity of the post-punk era to life. By exploring the evolution of genres like new wave, gothic rock, and synthpop, the author sheds light on the artists' influences and the cultural context that shaped their music. This not only enhances our appreciation for their work but also helps us understand the broader social and cultural impact of post-punk.

In addition to the music itself, Gimarc explores the political climate, fashion trends, and DIY ethos that characterized this era. This highlights the significance of post-punk as a reaction to mainstream culture. Through his expert analysis and commentary, the author offers valuable insights into how this genre challenged societal norms and paved the way for future musical movements.

"Post Punk Diary" is a fascinating and informative read that continues to inspire contemporary artists. With his thorough research, engaging writing style, and genuine passion for the subject, George Gimarc has created a valuable resource that captures the essence of the dynamic post-punk music era.

What are readers saying?

"Post Punk Diary" by George Gimarc has received a combination of positive and negative feedback from readers. Some readers have praised the book for its extensive and well-researched content, as well as the author's in-depth knowledge and ability to capture the essence of the post-punk music scene. They appreciated the detailed chronology, which offers insight into the development and evolution of the genre. The inclusion of personal anecdotes from Gimarc was seen as a unique and engaging addition, enhancing readers' understanding and enjoyment of the subject matter.

However, there were also readers who found the book lacking in certain areas. Some felt that Gimarc's writing style was dry and lacked the enthusiasm and energy often associated with the post-punk era. Others criticized the book for its lack of analysis and contextualization, suggesting that it primarily serves as a reference guide rather than a deep exploration of the subject. In addition, a few readers found the organization of the book confusing and sometimes difficult to follow.

Despite these criticisms, many readers still found "Post Punk Diary" to be a valuable resource and an excellent starting point for those interested in the subject. The book's extensive list of bands and their associated discographies was highly appreciated by music enthusiasts, providing a convenient reference for further exploration. The inclusion of rare photographs and illustrations also added visual appeal and enhanced the overall reading experience.

In summary, the reception to "Post Punk Diary" by George Gimarc has been mixed. While some readers praised the book for its comprehensive content and the author's knowledge and personal anecdotes, others found it lacking in certain areas. Nevertheless, many readers still found it to be a valuable resource for anyone interested in delving into the post-punk music scene, appreciating the extensive list of bands and visual elements included in the book.