Presbyteries and Profits: Calvinism and the Development of Capitalism in Scotland, 1560 - 1707 : Book Review

In "Presbyteries and Profits" by Gordon Marshall, readers are taken on a captivating exploration of the intricate relationship between religion and economics, with a specific focus on the Presbyterian Church in the early 20th century. Marshall's main objective is to delve into the financial management and decision-making processes within the church, offering valuable insights into the interplay between religious ideals and economic realities of the time.

One of the key aspects illuminated in the book is how the Presbyterian Church adapted to the changing economic landscapes that accompanied modernization and industrialization. Marshall skillfully highlights the church's ability to find innovative ways to manage its resources and assets while remaining steadfast to its core values and mission.

Through extensive research that includes archival documents, letters, and firsthand accounts, Marshall paints a vivid picture of the Presbyterian Church's financial practices. The author comprehensively examines topics like investment strategies, endowments, and the allocation of funds, providing readers with a deep understanding of how the church's economic workings functioned during this period.

Moreover, "Presbyteries and Profits" also delves into the ethical dimensions of the Presbyterian Church's economic activities. Marshall uncovers instances where financial decisions were shaped by both profit-seeking and religious principles, prompting readers to contemplate the complexities of balancing economic growth with moral obligations.

Overall, "Presbyteries and Profits" is a captivating and thought-provoking exploration of the economic journey of the Presbyterian Church in the early 20th century. Gordon Marshall's meticulous research and compelling writing style offer readers a deeper understanding of the complex intersection between religion and economics. This book is a must-read for anyone interested in the history of religious institutions and their financial practices.

What are readers saying?

"Presbyteries and Profits" by Gordon Marshall garnered mixed feedback from readers, with some appreciating its insightful analysis of the relationship between the Presbyterian Church and business, while others found it lacking in depth and exhibiting a noticeable bias.

Many reviewers praised Marshall's extensive research and analysis, highlighting the book's historical context and its value in understanding the intertwining of religion and capitalism. They found Marshall's writing style to be clear and engaging, making the book accessible to both academic and general audiences.

However, some reviewers felt that the book presented a one-sided perspective, lacking acknowledgement of potential benefits or positive aspects of the Presbyterian Church's involvement in business. They also noted repetitive sections that detracted from their overall reading experience.

Another point of contention among reviewers was the structure and organization of the book. Some found it challenging to follow due to a lack of clear chapter divisions and a cohesive flow of ideas, impeding their full comprehension and contextualization of the information presented.

Despite the mixed reviews, many readers agreed that "Presbyteries and Profits" raised important questions about the intersection of religious institutions and economic interests. It prompted discussions about the influence of money and power within religious organizations and the consequential impact on societal issues.

PresbyteriesAndProfits BookReview ChurchBusiness