Problems of the Self: Philosophical Papers 1956-1972 : Book Review

"Problems of the Self" by Bernard Williams offers an intriguing exploration of the concept of personal identity and the philosophical questions surrounding it. The book delves into various aspects of the self, including its continuity over time, its relationship to others, and the influence of morality and personal values.

Williams challenges traditional views that define personal identity based on physical characteristics or memories. Instead, he argues that our ongoing projects, commitments, and relationships should shape our understanding of who we are. He emphasizes the dynamic and complex nature of identity, rejecting the idea of a static and unchanging self.

A central idea in the book is the concept of the "narrative self." Williams suggests that we construct our sense of identity through the narratives we create about our lives. By integrating our actions, experiences, and future goals into a coherent story, we form a cohesive sense of self. He urges readers to reflect on the narratives they tell themselves and how these narratives shape their identity.

Furthermore, Williams explores the intricate relationship between personal identity and morality. He argues against the notion that moral actions are solely determined by a fixed and unchanging self. Instead, he suggests that our moral choices are influenced by a complex interplay of personal values and external factors, challenging the idea of a moral self detached from other aspects of our identity.

Overall, "Problems of the Self" is a thought-provoking examination of personal identity. Williams' nuanced arguments encourage readers to question conventional assumptions about the self and consider alternative perspectives. This book is essential reading for anyone interested in unraveling the philosophical complexities of personal identity and exploring the various factors that shape who we are.

What are readers saying?

"Problems of the Self" by Bernard Williams is an engaging and perceptive examination of the nature of personal identity and the difficulties individuals encounter in comprehending and defining themselves. This collection of essays has garnered a diverse array of reviews from readers.

Many readers admire Bernard Williams for his profound philosophical insights and his ability to address complex subjects with clarity and grace. They appreciate his exploration of the tension between individual freedom and societal influences on one's sense of self. Williams' nuanced analysis of authenticity and the imposition of societal expectations on individuals' is highly regarded.

Other readers value the book for its expansive range of topics. Williams delves into the challenges individuals face in defining their personal goals, the role emotions play in shaping identity, and the relationship between personal identity and moral responsibility. Readers commend his broad perspectives and interdisciplinary approach.

Some readers, however, find the book to be intellectually demanding and densly written. They note that a background in philosophy is necessary to fully grasp Williams' arguments, and the complex language and abstract concepts may alienate some readers, leaving them feeling overwhelmed or lost.

While many readers appreciate the depth of Williams' analysis, a few desire even greater exploration of certain subjects. They express a wish for more practical examples and real-life scenarios to illustrate his philosophical ideas and make them more applicable to everyday life.

selfreflection identitycrisis bookworm