Puccini's "Turandot": The End of the Great Tradition : Book Review
William Ashbrook's book, "Puccini's Turandot," offers readers a comprehensive and insightful exploration of Giacomo Puccini's final and unfinished opera, "Turandot." With a meticulous analysis of the opera's creation, Ashbrook sheds light on Puccini's intentions and the various influences that shaped this remarkable work.
One of the strengths of this book lies in its thorough examination of the opera's historical and cultural context. Ashbrook delves into Puccini's decision to base the story on a medieval Persian tale, providing valuable insights into the reasoning behind this choice. By understanding the origins and background of the opera, readers gain a deeper appreciation for Puccini's artistic vision.
Ashbrook's expertise in opera is evident throughout the book as he delves into the musical elements of "Turandot." With meticulous detail, he analyzes Puccini's composition style, exploring the nuances of the score and the impact it has on the overall dramatic effect. Musical enthusiasts will find this analysis particularly valuable, as it allows for a more profound understanding of Puccini's musical genius.
Available on Audible
In addition to the musical aspects, Ashbrook also explores the thematic elements of "Turandot." He examines the recurring motifs and symbols in the opera, uncovering the underlying messages and themes that Puccini intended to convey. By delving into these deeper layers, Ashbrook offers readers a comprehensive understanding of the opera's complexity and depth.
Furthermore, Ashbrook examines the reception of "Turandot" among both audiences and critics. He explores the initial reactions to the opera and how it was received in different cultural and historical contexts. This analysis provides valuable insights into the opera's cultural significance and its enduring popularity among audiences worldwide.
What are readers saying?
"Turandot," by William Ashbrook, has elicited varying responses from readers. The book offers a detailed exploration of Giacomo Puccini's unfinished opera, Turandot. While some readers praised the book's thorough analysis and historical context, others felt it fell short in certain aspects.
One reviewer applauded Ashbrook's extensive research and knowledge of Puccini's work. They noted that the book delved into the historical background, musical structure, and cultural influences that shaped Turandot, providing a rich and insightful reading experience. Another reader appreciated how Ashbrook provided an in-depth analysis of the opera's libretto, different versions, and creative decisions made by Puccini during the composition process.
However, some readers expressed concerns about the book's consistency and clarity. One reviewer mentioned that the book's structure was occasionally confusing, making it challenging to follow the narrative. Another critic felt that Ashbrook's writing style at times came off as dry and academic, thereby making it difficult for non-experts to fully grasp the material.
Despite these criticisms, many readers found the book to be a valuable resource. Some praised the inclusion of musical examples and illustrations, which aided in understanding Puccini's artistic choices. In addition, Ashbrook's exploration of the political and social context during the time Turandot was created was regarded as insightful and thought-provoking.
Overall, William Ashbrook's "Puccini's Turandot" has sparked a range of responses from readers. While some appreciated its comprehensive analysis and historical context, others found issues with its structure and writing style. Despite these flaws, many still regarded the book as an important resource for understanding Puccini's final opera.
Puccini Turandot Opera