Punk Diary: The Ultimate Trainspotter's Guide to Underground Rock, 1970-1982 : Book Review

"Punk Diary" by George Gimarc is an incredibly comprehensive and captivating exploration of the punk rock music scene from 1970 to 1979. Gimarc's vast knowledge and unwavering passion for the subject shine through in this meticulously researched and extensively detailed account. The book takes readers on a day-by-day journey, chronicling significant events, concerts, album releases, and noteworthy moments in punk rock history.

What sets Gimarc's writing apart is his clear and concise style, brimming with engaging anecdotes and stories that truly bring the era to life. He perfectly captures the raw energy and rebellious spirit of the punk movement, while also delving into its cultural and social impact. Through the diary format, readers are able to immerse themselves in the music and events of each day, transforming the book into an interactive and captivating experience.

One of the book's greatest strengths is the staggering amount of information it provides. Not only does it thoroughly cover the major bands and artists of the time, but it also delves into lesser-known acts and regional scenes, offering readers a comprehensive view of the punk rock landscape. Gimarc's dedication to his subject is evident in the extensive research he has undertaken, resulting in a book that will appeal to both casual fans and hardcore enthusiasts alike.

Furthermore, "Punk Diary" features a plethora of photographs and illustrations, serving to visually enhance the reading experience and bring the punk rock era to life. From glimpses of punk fashion to electrifying live performances, these images provide a valuable visual record that further contextualizes the events described in the diary entries.

In conclusion, "Punk Diary" by George Gimarc is an essential read for anyone fascinated by punk rock music and its cultural significance. Its detailed day-by-day account, captivating writing style, and rich visual content offer readers a comprehensive and immersive journey through the punk rock era. Whether you're a devoted fan or new to the genre, this book is an invaluable resource that captures the very spirit and essence of punk rock.

What are readers saying?

George Gimarc's book "Punk Diary" has received mixed reviews from readers. The book offers a comprehensive exploration of the punk rock scene from 1970 to 1982. However, opinions on its execution vary among readers.

Some readers praise the book for its extensive research and detailed information. They appreciate its wide coverage, including anecdotes, interviews, and historical context. These readers commend Gimarc's dedication to capturing the essence of the punk movement and its various subgenres. They find the book to be a valuable resource for both longtime fans and newcomers to the punk scene.

On the other hand, some readers feel that the book falls short in certain aspects. They find the writing style to be chaotic and disjointed, making it difficult to follow the timeline and fully engage with the material. The lack of a clear narrative structure is criticized, as it can make the book feel like a collection of random facts rather than a cohesive story. Additionally, a few reviewers note that the book focuses heavily on the American punk scene, neglecting important contributions from the UK and other countries.

Despite these criticisms, many readers appreciate the inclusion of rare photos and memorabilia, which enhance the reading experience and provide a unique perspective on the punk movement. The book's attention to detail and dedication to showcasing the vibrant imagery of the era leave a positive impression on these readers.

Some reviewers express disappointment in the lack of analysis and deeper exploration of the social and cultural impact of punk. They argue that the book falls short in capturing the essence and significance of the movement beyond a surface-level documentation of events and bands. These readers were hoping for more thoughtful insights into the motivations and ideologies of the punk rockers.

PunkDiary MusicMemoir SubcultureChronicle