Redburn: Works of Herman Melville Volume Four : Book Review

"Redburn" by Herman Melville is a captivating coming-of-age novel that delves deep into themes of identity, society, and the complex nature of being human. The story follows the journey of Wellingborough Redburn, a young and inexperienced teenager, as he sets sail on his first voyage aboard a merchant ship.

Throughout the novel, Melville skillfully exposes the hardships endured by sailors, offering readers a glimpse into the harsh realities of life at sea. Redburn’s observations and interactions shed light on the stark contrast between appearances and reality, revealing the superficiality and cruelty embedded in social hierarchies.

One of the most compelling aspects of "Redburn" is the transformation of the central character. Redburn begins his journey as an innocent and idealistic youth, but as he navigates through adversity, he matures and gains a deeper understanding of the world. Melville's vivid descriptions of the diverse characters Redburn encounters on his voyage further enhance the book's exploration of the complexities of human nature and the challenges of navigating different social classes.

What sets "Redburn" apart is its critique of the American Dream. Redburn witnesses firsthand the struggles of immigrants who come to America seeking a better life, only to discover the harsh realities that await them. This examination of the American Dream adds a layer of depth and relevance to the story, highlighting issues of identity, class, and social mobility that are still significant today.

Overall, "Redburn" is a thought-provoking and insightful novel that showcases Melville's masterful storytelling ability. With its rich character development, poignant social commentary, and exploration of identity and society, this novel remains a fascinating read for anyone interested in classic literature.

What are readers saying?

The reception of Herman Melville's book Redburn has been a topic of debate among readers. Opinions on the novel are divided, with some finding it to be a captivating coming-of-age story filled with insights. These readers praised Melville's vivid descriptions of life at sea and the hardships faced by the protagonist, Wellingborough Redburn. They commended the depth of the characters and Redburn's emotional journey throughout the book. The writing style was hailed as rich and engaging, with readers appreciating Melville's knack for creating a sense of realism.

However, there were also readers who struggled to connect with Redburn. They felt that the novel lacked a clear plot and found certain sections to be slow and tedious. These readers believed that the elaborate descriptions, while beautifully written, were excessive and distracting. The lack of action in the story left them disappointed, as they desired a more fast-paced narrative.

Some reviewers highlighted the presence of social commentary in Redburn as a strong aspect of the book. They appreciated how Melville delved into themes of class and inequality through Redburn's encounters with different social groups. These readers found the novel to be thought-provoking, praising Melville's ability to address societal issues through his characters and their experiences.

Contrarily, some readers found the social commentary to be heavy-handed and overt. They believed that Melville's message was too obvious, leaving little room for interpretation. These reviewers expressed a preference for Melville's other works, such as Moby-Dick, over Redburn.

In conclusion, Redburn by Herman Melville has generated mixed reviews, with some readers embracing the vivid descriptions and coming-of-age story, while others struggled with the lack of plot and excessive details. The novel's social commentary was both praised for its thoughtfulness and criticized for being heavy-handed. Ultimately, opinions on Redburn varied, suggesting that it may appeal more to fans of Melville's writing style and thematic choices.

Redburn ClassicNovel SailorStory