Remaking History and Other Stories : Book Review

"Remaking History and Other Stories" by Kim Stanley Robinson is a captivating collection of short science fiction stories that takes readers on imaginative and thought-provoking journeys. From the depths of the ocean to the reaches of outer space, Robinson explores various themes and settings in a way that keeps readers engrossed until the very end.

The title story, "Remaking History," delves into the concept of altering the past through technology, raising intriguing questions about the ethics and consequences of such actions. This storyline keeps readers engaged, eager to discover the outcomes of manipulating history.

Throughout the collection, Robinson also delves into ecological issues and the impact of human activity on the environment. Stories like "Fire Ant" vividly describe the consequences of our actions, sparking reflection on our own impact on the planet. Robinson's attention to detail and ability to create believable and immersive worlds make these environmental themes even more compelling.

One particularly standout story is "A Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions," which explores chaos theory and the butterfly effect. Robinson skillfully blends scientific concepts with storytelling, demonstrating that small actions can have far-reaching consequences. This thought-provoking tale makes readers consider the impact of their own choices and actions.

"Remaking History and Other Stories" also delves into the realm of space exploration. Stories like "Our Town" and "The Lucky Strike" offer unique perspectives on the future of humanity in the cosmos, tackling themes of colonization, human resilience, and the challenges of interstellar travel. Robinson's ability to weave these themes into narratives that captivate readers is truly impressive.

What are readers saying?

"Remaking History and Other Stories" by Kim Stanley Robinson is a collection of science fiction short stories that has garnered a range of reviews from readers. The first story, "Venice Drowned," has received praise for its vivid descriptions and well-researched historical backdrop. Readers are captivated by Robinson's ability to transport them to a submerged Venice in a future affected by climate change. Within the story, the lives of the characters are intricately explored, shedding light on environmental issues and their societal implications. Critics commend Robinson for his thought-provoking analysis of the consequences stemming from global warming.

Nonetheless, some readers have found fault with the collection, specifically noting that the stories can be excessively verbose and excessively descriptive. While appreciating Robinson's attention to detail, these readers suggest that it can impede the pace and enjoyment of the narratives. In particular, "Remaking History" has been mentioned as a story that lacks a clear direction and feels drawn out.

The collection also contains stories centered around time travel and alternate history, such as "The Lucky Strike" and "A Sensitive Dependence on Initial Conditions." These stories have garnered mixed feedback. Some readers appreciate the intellectual depth and complex storytelling, praising Robinson's innovative and challenging ideas. However, others found the concepts confusing and difficult to follow, thereby detracting from their overall enjoyment of the book.

A common sentiment expressed by many readers concerns the presence of political commentary in Robinson's stories. While some appreciate the integration of social and political themes into the narratives, others feel that they are heavy-handed and distracting. This inclusion of overt political messaging leaves some readers feeling as though they are being lectured rather than being afforded the opportunity to draw their own conclusions.

In conclusion, "Remaking History and Other Stories" is a collection that showcases both strengths and weaknesses. Readers appreciate Robinson's ability to create immersive settings and explore topical issues. However, the book's lengthy descriptions, confusing concepts, and heavy-handed politics have also garnered criticism from some readers.

RemakingHistory ShortStories BookRecommendations