"Rising Up and Rising Down" by William T. Vollmann is an incredibly extensive exploration of violence, examining its justifications throughout history. This thought-provoking and ambitious seven-volume work offers a comprehensive analysis of violence from various perspectives.
Vollmann covers a wide range of topics, delving into war, terrorism, self-defense, and genocide, and exploring the motives and consequences of violent actions. Through extensive research, historical examples, interviews, and personal anecdotes, the author provides a solid foundation for his arguments. The writing style is scholarly yet accessible, making this complex subject matter approachable for readers from all backgrounds.
One of the remarkable strengths of "Rising Up and Rising Down" lies in Vollmann's ability to tackle such a sensitive and multifaceted topic with nuance and empathy. He challenges common assumptions and offers thought-provoking insights into the complexities of violence. Through his analysis, Vollmann encourages readers to question their own beliefs and attitudes towards violence.
Available on Audible
Throughout the seven volumes, Vollmann also explores the role of the individual when faced with violence, discussing ethics, responsibility, and the choices people make in dire circumstances. By examining different historical periods and diverse cultures, he provides a more comprehensive understanding of the human capacity for violence and the ethical dilemmas it presents.
"Rising Up and Rising Down" is a thought-provoking and meticulously researched exploration of violence, its motivations, and its consequences. Vollmann's comprehensive analysis challenges readers to confront their own beliefs about violence, making it a valuable resource for anyone seeking to understand this complex aspect of human nature.
What are readers saying?
"Rising Up and Rising Down," authored by William T. Vollmann, offers a deep and thought-provoking examination of violence, ethics, and power dynamics. The book ventures into the intricate realm of human aggression, presenting a comprehensive review of violent acts both in historical and contemporary contexts.
Critics laud Vollmann's meticulous research and thorough analysis, appreciating his scholarly approach to dissecting the subject matter. His exploration of violence goes beyond simplistic moral judgments, prompting readers to question their own beliefs and assumptions.
The book covers a wide range of topics, including warfare, terrorism, state-sponsored violence, and personal aggression, impressing readers with its inclusive scope. Vollmann draws insights from historical events, personal interviews, and firsthand accounts, providing a well-rounded and enlightening narrative. Many reviewers highlight how this breadth of coverage contributes to a deeper understanding of the diverse factors that contribute to acts of violence.
Vollmann's writing style is often described as dense and demanding, requiring readers to approach the material with patience and concentration. While some readers appreciate the intellectual rigor, others find it overwhelming and challenging to digest. Additionally, the book's substantial length, exceeding 3,500 pages in certain editions, may deter those seeking a more concise exploration of the subject.
Critics of the book argue that Vollmann's subjective experiences and beliefs overshadow an objective examination of violence, perceiving a biased perspective. On the other hand, proponents of the book contend that Vollmann's personal insights bring depth and nuance to his arguments.
RisingUpAndRisingDown BookReview ReadingList