Rough Crossings: Britain, the Slaves and the American Revolution : Book Review

"Rough Crossings" by Simon Schama tells the often overlooked story of African American loyalists who escaped slavery during the American Revolution by joining the British forces. The book offers a comprehensive narrative of their courageous journey from enslavement to freedom, including their resettlement in Nova Scotia and eventual migration to Sierra Leone.

Schama expertly weaves together historical facts, personal stories, and vivid descriptions to create a captivating account of the challenges faced by these brave individuals. He sheds light on the harsh realities of slavery and the difficult decision to side with the British, who promised freedom to those who fought alongside them. Drawing from meticulously researched records and testimonials, the author brings these forgotten heroes to life, allowing readers to empathize with their struggles.

One of the strengths of "Rough Crossings" lies in Schama's ability to provide a balanced perspective of the complexities surrounding the American Revolution and the role of African Americans within it. He explores the contradictions of a revolution fighting for freedom while still perpetuating slavery, revealing the tensions between the ideals of the American Patriots and the experiences of African American loyalists.

Another notable aspect of the book is Schama's emphasis on the aftermath of the war and the challenges faced by the African American loyalists in their new homes. From the disillusionment with the British promises of land and freedom, to the difficulties in adapting to unfamiliar environments, the author delves into the complex realities of their post-war lives.

Overall, "Rough Crossings" is a profound and poignant account that highlights the struggles and triumphs of African American loyalists during a pivotal era in history. Schama's meticulous research, engaging storytelling, and thought-provoking analysis make this book a captivating read for anyone seeking to understand the complexities of the American Revolution and its lasting impact on marginalized communities.

What are readers saying?

Simon Schama's "Rough Crossings" has garnered a range of responses from readers, with some offering praise and others expressing criticism. The book delves into the history of African American slaves who sought freedom during the American Revolution and eventually made their way to Nova Scotia and Sierra Leone.

Several reviewers admired Schama's extensive research and captivating storytelling. They appreciated the vivid descriptions that brought to life the struggles and victories of the African American slaves. These readers found "Rough Crossings" to be an enlightening and thought-provoking account of a lesser-known aspect of American history.

Others, however, found fault with the book's excessive detail and density, making it challenging to follow at times. Some also felt that Schama's writing style leaned towards the academic, potentially alienating readers seeking a more casual read. A few reviewers mentioned a desire for deeper exploration of the experiences of the African American slaves and greater analytical insights.

Despite these criticisms, many readers appreciated "Rough Crossings" for shedding light on an often neglected chapter of history. They commended Schama for his thorough research and his skill in connecting various historical events. The book serves as an important reminder of the intricacies of the American Revolution and its impact on marginalized communities.

In conclusion, "Rough Crossings" provides a distinctive perspective on the African American experience during the American Revolution. While some readers found the book overly detailed and written in an academic style, others praised its comprehensive research and compelling narrative. It is a valuable read for those interested in exploring lesser-known aspects of American history and the challenges faced by marginalized communities during this period.

RoughCrossings SlaveryandFreedom HistoricalNonFiction