Saloons of the Old West : Book Review

In "Saloons of the Old West," Richard Erdoes invites readers on a captivating journey through the thriving saloons of the American frontier. From rowdy and lawless establishments to refined bars in booming mining towns, Erdoes explores the social and cultural significance of these iconic venues.

Erdoes skillfully paints a vivid picture of saloon culture, offering a detailed account of the daily life and activities that unfolded within these bustling establishments. He delves into the unique role saloons played in the lives of pioneers, cowboys, and outlaws, shedding light on the social dynamics, entertainment, and vices that permeated the era.

One of the book's strengths lies in Erdoes' ability to breathe life into historical figures and events, allowing readers to feel as if they are witnessing history firsthand. Through his storytelling, readers are introduced to legendary characters like Wild Bill Hickok and Calamity Jane, who frequented these saloons and left an indelible mark on the Old West.

Erdoes also explores the architecture and design of these iconic saloons, highlighting their distinctive features and ambiance. He uncovers the elements that transformed these establishments into gathering places for individuals from all walks of life, ranging from rough-and-tumble cowboys to sophisticated businessmen. The inclusion of rich illustrations, including photographs and drawings, further enhances the visual experience for readers.

Overall, "Saloons of the Old West" is a captivating book for history enthusiasts and those fascinated by the Wild West era. Through his engaging storytelling and meticulous research, Richard Erdoes successfully captures the allure and significance of these old saloons, offering a glimpse into a bygone era of American history.

What are readers saying?

"Saloons of the Old West" by Richard Erdoes has received a mixed reception from readers. While some reviewers appreciated the book's immersive portrayal of saloons in the Old West, others found it lacking depth and substance. The detailed and engaging writing style of Erdoes was commended by some, as it brought to life the dusty and rowdy atmosphere of these establishments, effectively transporting readers to a different era. These readers also enjoyed the historical context provided by the book, which enriched their understanding of the saloons.

On the contrary, some readers felt that the book fell short in terms of analysis and storytelling. They found the content repetitive and desired a more comprehensive exploration of the saloons, rather than a collection of anecdotes. Additionally, the book's organization was criticized by a few readers, noting that the chapters did not flow smoothly and lacked cohesiveness. As a result, it was challenging for them to fully engage with the material and grasp the overall message that Erdoes intended to convey.

However, the inclusion of historical photographs and illustrations in the book received praise from some readers. These visual aids were seen as enhancing their understanding and enjoyment of the subject matter. The effort put into research and sourcing of these visuals was appreciated by these readers, as it added value to their reading experience.

Overall, "Saloons of the Old West" offers readers an intriguing glimpse into the cultural and social aspects of the time, making it an enjoyable read for history enthusiasts and those interested in the Old West. Nevertheless, it is important to note that some readers cautioned against expecting a comprehensive and scholarly examination of the subject matter.