Scapegoats of the Empire: The True Story of Breaker Morant's Bushveldt Carbineers : Book Review

"Scapegoats of the Empire" by George Witton offers a captivating and enlightening exploration of the British Empire's troubled past. Witton, a former British officer, shares his own compelling story of being falsely accused and sentenced to death for war crimes during the Boer War. Supported by official documents and testimonies, Witton unveils the injustices and corruption that plagued the British military during that era.

The book provides a vivid depiction of Witton's experiences as a young soldier in South Africa, shedding light on the brutal conditions and atrocities committed by the British forces. Witton's storytelling is both engaging and evocative, allowing readers to truly comprehend the fear, confusion, and despair he endured. Through his personal perspective, the narrative becomes all the more immersive.

Furthermore, "Scapegoats of the Empire" goes beyond Witton's personal ordeal to examine the larger context of the war and the systemic issues within the British Empire. It raises crucial questions about accountability and the abuse of power within military hierarchies. Witton's meticulous research and analysis reveal how innocent soldiers became victims of political agendas and scapegoats for military leaders.

The book also emphasizes Witton's fight for justice as he battles against his wrongful conviction. His determination and resilience serve as an inspiration and a rallying cry for reform within the British Army. His struggle exposes the flaws and inconsistencies in the legal system and underscores the urgent need for justice to prevail.

In sum, "Scapegoats of the Empire" is a thought-provoking and poignant account that exposes a dark chapter in history. Witton's personal story and thorough research make this book essential for anyone interested in comprehending the complexities of imperialism and the relentless quest for truth and justice. It serves as a powerful reminder of the necessity to hold those in power accountable, even in the face of overwhelming adversity.

What are readers saying?

"Scapegoats of the Empire" written by George Witton has received varied reviews from readers on Goodreads. The book delves into the injustices and unfair treatment faced by Australian soldiers during the Boer War.

Overall, readers commended the book for shedding light on a lesser-known aspect of history. They found the topic intriguing and appreciated the author's efforts in bringing attention to the mistreatment of Australian soldiers. Reviewers particularly lauded the book for providing a unique perspective on the Boer War and delving into the experiences of those who were wrongly accused and sentenced to death.

However, some readers expressed disappointment with the book's execution. They felt that the writing style was monotonous and lacked engaging storytelling. Several reviewers found it challenging to stay engaged with the material as the narrative frequently became mired in unnecessary details and tangents. Some also suggested that the book would have benefitted from more meticulous editing to streamline the content.

Furthermore, a few readers remarked that the book lacked depth in its analysis of the events and did not sufficiently explore the sociopolitical context of the time. They believed that the author could have provided additional background information to enhance readers' comprehension of the characters' actions and motivations.

Despite these criticisms, most readers agreed that "Scapegoats of the Empire" makes a significant contribution to understanding Australian history and the injustices faced by its soldiers. They commended the author for his thorough research and unwavering dedication to shedding light on this oft-forgotten chapter.

ScapegoatsOfTheEmpire HistoricalInjustice ColonialLegacy