Self-Made Men: Identity and Embodiment Among Transsexual Men : Book Review

"Self-Made Men" by Henry Rubin is a captivating and compassionate exploration of the transgender community. As a professor of anthropology and women's and gender studies, Rubin takes a unique approach by conducting intimate interviews with transgender men, allowing their personal stories and experiences to take center stage. Through these interviews, Rubin sheds light on the complexities of gender identity and the struggles faced by these men.

One of the book's strengths lies in Rubin's ability to present a diverse range of transgender men from various backgrounds, ages, and professions. By showcasing this diversity, readers gain a deeper understanding of the challenges and triumphs faced by transgender individuals in their everyday lives. Whether it's navigating relationships, parenthood, or work, Rubin's subjects provide a firsthand account of their experiences, challenging preconceived notions and stereotypes along the way.

Rubin's approach to these interviews is empathetic and respectful, allowing the voices of his subjects to shine through. He provides a platform for their narratives without judgment or sensationalism, ensuring that their stories are heard and understood. By doing so, Rubin emphasizes the importance of individual autonomy in defining one's gender identity.

"Self-Made Men" not only focuses on individual stories, but also explores critical themes within the transgender community. Rubin addresses issues such as healthcare access, discrimination, and social acceptance, shedding light on the systemic challenges faced by transgender men. Through these discussions, the book serves as a call for greater understanding, empathy, and support for the transgender community.

In conclusion, "Self-Made Men" is a truly insightful and compassionate exploration of transgender men's experiences. Rubin's approach humanizes the transgender community, amplifying their stories and fostering a deeper understanding of gender identity. This book is an invaluable resource for anyone seeking to learn more about the struggles faced by transgender men and the importance of acceptance and support.

What are readers saying?

Henry Rubin's book, "Self-Made Men," has garnered a range of opinions from readers. The book delves into the lives of transgender men, and while some reviewers have praised its depth and empathetic approach, others have criticized its writing style and lack of inclusivity.

Many readers appreciate Rubin's exploration of transgender men's experiences, finding it enlightening and educational. They commend his ability to shed light on a topic that is often misunderstood or overlooked. The book is seen as an opportunity to understand the challenges and triumphs faced by these individuals, and many admire Rubin's empathetic portrayal.

Conversely, some readers find fault with Rubin's writing style, deeming it overly academic and lacking personal connection. They argue that the book fails to adequately capture the emotional journeys of the individuals it profiles, which diminishes their overall enjoyment. The disconnect between the readers and the characters' stories detracts from their appreciation of the book.

Criticism also arises regarding the book's narrow focus on white, middle-class transgender men, which some argue limits its representational scope. Readers suggest that a more inclusive approach would have made the book more comprehensive and relatable to a wider range of individuals. They express disappointment with the lack of diverse experiences portrayed in the book.

Furthermore, reviewers highlight the book's lack of intersectionality. They argue that Rubin fails to adequately address issues related to race, class, and other social factors, which hampers its ability to provide a comprehensive understanding of the subject matter.

SelfMadeMen BookRecommendations PersonalGrowth