Shattered Air: A True Account of Catastrophe and Courage on Yosemite's Half Dome : Book Review

"Shattered Air" by Bob Madgic is an incredibly gripping and intense account of a tragic incident that unfolded in the skies above California in 1985. The book tells the story of a private Cessna plane that collided with a Pacific Southwest Airlines Flight, resulting in the loss of all onboard. Madgic's meticulous attention to detail allows readers to truly understand the lives of the victims and the circumstances that led to this fateful collision.

Madgic's writing style is captivating and informative, offering readers a deep dive into the lives and backgrounds of those involved. Through extensive research and interviews with witnesses and survivors, the author provides a comprehensive account that goes beyond just the technical aspects of the incident. Readers are able to connect with the victims on a personal level, gaining a profound understanding of the impact their lives had on their loved ones.

One of the remarkable strengths of "Shattered Air" is Madgic's ability to maintain suspense throughout the narrative, even though the outcome of the collision is known from the beginning. The author artfully weaves together the different stories and perspectives, keeping readers on edge and craving more information. Madgic's attention to detail is also apparent as he delves into the subsequent investigation, shedding light on the flaws and shortcomings of the aviation industry.

Beyond being a typical disaster narrative, "Shattered Air" offers a thought-provoking exploration of the human aspect of tragedy. Madgic delves into the personal struggles and emotional turmoil of the victims, as well as the profound impact their deaths had on their families and communities. The book serves as a poignant reminder that behind every disaster are real individuals with hopes, dreams, and loved ones left behind.

In summary, "Shattered Air" is a deeply compelling and well-researched book that will captivate readers interested in true crime, aviation history, or human psychology. Madgic's ability to infuse technical details with raw human emotion makes this an engaging read from beginning to end.

What are readers saying?

The reception to Bob Madgic's book, "Shattered Air," has been varied among readers. The book recounts the tragic Air California crash of 1978, offering a gripping and true account of the events leading up to the disaster, the harrowing moments of the crash itself, and the aftermath. However, opinions differ on the book's effectiveness in capturing the emotional impact of the tragedy and its overall depth.

Many readers found "Shattered Air" to be a captivating and informative read. They praised the author for his meticulous research, which involved interviewing survivors, investigators, and first responders. This attention to detail resulted in vivid descriptions that brought the tragedy to life and made it feel real and substantial. Readers appreciated the author's ability to convey the complexities of the aviation industry and crash investigations.

On the other hand, some reviewers felt that "Shattered Air" fell short in delivering the emotional impact of the story. The writing style was criticized as dry and clinical, lacking the depth and empathy needed to connect with the characters and their experiences. A number of readers expressed a desire for more personal narratives and a deeper exploration of the psychological aftermath of the crash.

Opinions also differed on the book's structure. While some found the non-linear storytelling style engaging and suspenseful, others found it confusing and hindering their understanding of the events. Additionally, some readers struggled to keep track of the numerous characters introduced throughout the book.

In summary, "Shattered Air" by Bob Madgic has received mixed reviews. While it has been praised for its thorough research and ability to provide insights into the aviation industry, some readers have expressed a desire for more emotional depth and a clearer narrative structure.

ShatteredAir BookRecommendation EmotionalJourney