Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa: Iqbal's Dialogue with Allah : Book Review

"Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa" is an extraordinary collection of poetry penned by the esteemed philosopher and poet, Muhammad Iqbal. The book comprises two exceptional poems, "Shikwa" (Complaint) and "Jawab-i-Shikwa" (Response to the Complaint), both delving into the realms of faith, spirituality, and the intricate dynamics between humanity and the divine.

In "Shikwa," Iqbal portrays his disillusionment and disappointment with the state of the Muslim community with eloquence and grace. Through evocative metaphors and vivid imagery, he contemplates the declining status of Muslims and implores God to elucidate the reasons behind this regression. This poetic masterpiece serves as a wake-up call, urging Muslims to introspect and strive for a brighter future.

"Jawab-i-Shikwa" stands as an illuminating response to the grievances put forth in the preceding poem. Within this breathtaking piece, Iqbal skillfully interweaves verses of hope, faith, and redemption. He reminds Muslims of their inherent qualities that have the power to transform their circumstances, emphasizing that genuine change originates from within. The poem encapsulates the essence of Iqbal's philosophical beliefs and acts as an inspirational and motivational force for its readers.

Throughout this book, Muhammad Iqbal's poetic brilliance radiates effortlessly. His skillful use of intricate language and profound symbolism lends depth and meaning to his verses, providing a delightful feast for poetry enthusiasts. Additionally, the themes explored in "Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa" hold relevance not only to the time in which they were written but also resonate with the present-day context. These poems implore readers to reflect upon their own actions and question societal norms, rendering it a thought-provoking read.

In conclusion, "Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa" is a timeless masterpiece that showcases Muhammad Iqbal's genius as both a poet and philosopher. It is a book that not only offers profound insights into the nature of faith and the human condition but also challenges readers to take ownership of their actions. Whether one is familiar with Iqbal's work or new to the world of poetry, this collection is an absolute must-read for those seeking spiritual and intellectual enlightenment.

What are readers saying?

The book "Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa" by Muhammad Iqbal has garnered a mixed reception from readers. The general consensus suggests that the book possesses both strengths and weaknesses, with readers praising its evocative poetry while criticizing its lack of accessibility and challenging language.

Many readers appreciate and find value in the powerful and thought-provoking nature of the poetry found in "Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa." They admire Muhammad Iqbal's skillful use of language and imagery, finding it deeply moving and able to evoke strong emotions. The book is lauded for its profound exploration of philosophical themes, particularly in its examination of the complex relationship between humans and God.

However, some reviewers note that the book's complex language and metaphors can be a barrier to understanding. They feel that a deep knowledge of Urdu and Islamic theology is necessary to fully grasp the meaning and nuances of the poetry. This can be a deterrent for some readers, who may find it daunting and discouraging, ultimately restricting its accessibility to a wider audience.

Moreover, a few readers mention the need for proper translations and explanations, particularly for those who are not familiar with Islamic concepts. They suggest that the inclusion of footnotes or annotations would greatly enhance the reading experience and assist readers in navigating the intricate layers of meaning within the poems.

Despite these criticisms, numerous readers acknowledge the historical significance of "Shikwa and Jawab-i-Shikwa" and its profound impact on Urdu literature. They value the political and social commentary interwoven within the poetry, recognizing its relevance and applicability even in present times. Some reviewers consider the book essential for those seeking to delve into the cultural and intellectual heritage of South Asia.

ShikwaAndJawabIShikwa UrduPoetry Iqbal